01
Best overall pick
Joey's Italian Grill
Madison Village Center • Full-Service Italian Restaurant With A Serious Pizza Menu • Local Favorite For Dine-In Pizza
A sit-down Italian spot where the pizza is every bit as popular as the pasta and parm.
Joey's is the place Madison residents name first when you ask where to grab a good pizza and linger over dinner. The pies have a sturdy, flavorful crust with plenty of topping options, from classic pepperoni to heavier specialty combinations. It’s a comfortable choice when you want real plates, a full bar, and a pizza that feels a little more like a night out than a takeout box.
02
Classic neighborhood slice shop
Karen's Holiday Pizza
East Madison Near Route 20 • Old-School Takeout And Delivery Pizzeria • Best For Carry-Out Pies
A long-running local shop turning out straightforward, generously topped pizzas at fair prices.
Karen's Holiday Pizza feels like the kind of small-town pizzeria people grow up with—no frills, just familiar, well-loaded pies. The crust leans toward classic Midwest style, sturdy enough to handle extra cheese and toppings without going soggy. It’s a go-to for takeout nights, especially if you’re feeding a crowd and want something local instead of a big chain.
03
Game-day takeout staple
Capps Pizza
West Madison Near I-90 • Casual Regional Chain Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups And Shareable Pies
A regional favorite known for hearty, shareable pizzas that suit busy weeknights and game days.
Capps Pizza serves the kind of hearty, cheese-forward pies that work well for football Sundays and kids’ sleepovers. Crusts are thicker and satisfying, with crowd-pleasing toppings and plenty of combination options to keep everyone happy. Add wings or subs to the order and you can feed a whole group with one easy pickup stop on your way through town.
04
Family-friendly chain option
Pizza Hut
North Ridge Road Strip • National Chain Pizzeria With Dine-In And Carry-Out • Most Familiar Pick For Families
A reliable choice when you want stuffed crust, kid-pleasing sides, and predictable deals.
Madison’s Pizza Hut draws families and teams with its mix of classic pan pizzas, stuffed crust, and easy-to-share sides. The menu is predictable in a good way, so out-of-town visitors know exactly what they’re getting. It’s especially handy if you’re coming off Route 20 or I-90 and need a quick, no-debate option everyone in the car can agree on.
05
Fast late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
Hubbard Road Corridor • Delivery-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Best For Fast, Trackable Delivery
Domino’s is the go-to when speed, online ordering, and consistent pies matter more than ambiance.
For many Madison households, Domino’s is the default on nights when cooking is not in the cards and the game has already started. The ability to customize crust, sauces, and toppings online and watch the order tracker in real time is a big draw. While it’s not a special-occasion pie, it reliably shows up hot, fast, and exactly how you ordered it.