01
Best overall pick
Benny's Pizza Pub & Patio
Marysville (South Of Magnetic Springs) • Lively Local Pizza Pub With Big Patio • Local Favorite
A bustling Marysville staple known for hearty pies, live music, and a huge patio that draws crowds from all over Union County.
If you ask folks around Magnetic Springs where they actually go for pizza, Benny’s is usually the first name you hear. The crust is sturdy and chewy, toppings are generous, and the menu is broad enough to keep a group happy. Aim for an evening when there’s live music, grab a spot on the patio, and split a large specialty pie with friends.
02
Best for fast, reliable delivery
Domino's Pizza
Marysville (Us‑33 Corridor) • National Delivery Chain • Late-Night Standby
A go-to option when you want a hot pizza run out to the countryside without much fuss.
For Magnetic Springs households, the Marysville Domino’s is the practical choice on busy weeknights or late-game nights. Delivery drivers are used to heading out on the back roads, and online ordering makes it easy to customize sauces, crusts, and extras. It’s not a special-occasion spot, but it’s exactly what you want when convenience is the priority.
03
Best for sit-down chain comfort
Pizza Hut
Marysville (Near Shopping Strip) • Classic Dine-In Pizza Chain • Best For Families
A familiar red-roof experience with pan pizzas, breadsticks, and roomy booths for family dinners.
If you’re out running errands in Marysville and want an easy place to sit down with kids or a mixed group, Pizza Hut still does the job. The pan crust is the star here, crispy at the edges with plenty of cheese and sauce, and the buffet or combo deals keep costs in check. It’s the kind of spot where no one has to overthink the order—just pick a couple of pies and dig in.
04
Best for a night out
Amato's Woodfired Pizza
Delaware (Near Downtown) • Wood-Fired Italian Pizzeria • Best For Date Night
A cozy Delaware favorite turning out blistered, wood-fired pies with a more grown-up feel than the chains.
When you want pizza to feel like a proper evening out, make the extra drive to Amato’s in Delaware. The thin, wood-fired crust comes out with a bit of char and a light chew, and toppings trend more Italian—think fresh mozzarella, basil, and cured meats. Pair a pie with a salad and a glass of wine, and you’ve got a relaxed date-night or small-group spot that still feels casual.
05
Best for thick-crust cravings
Jet's Pizza
Delaware (Shopping Corridor) • Detroit-Style Carryout And Delivery Spot • Best For Thick-Crust Fans
Known for square, cheesy-edged Detroit-style pies that travel surprisingly well back to Magnetic Springs.
Jet’s is the pick when you’re in the mood for something heavier and more indulgent than a standard round pie. The signature Detroit-style pizza has a crunchy, caramelized cheese edge, airy interior, and plenty of sauce and toppings. Call ahead before you leave Delaware or order online so your box is coming out of the oven just as you pull up.