01
Best overall pick
Teresa's Pizza
Mantua Village • Classic Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Reliable, generously topped pies right in the heart of Mantua.
Teresa's is the go-to option when you want solid, no-fuss pizza without leaving the village. The crust is sturdy enough for loaded toppings, and their classic pepperoni and sausage combos hit the spot after a game or a day on the river. Call ahead on weekend evenings, as locals know this is one of the easiest wins for takeout.
02
Worth the short drive
Cal's II Pizza & Cheesesteaks
Downtown Garrettsville • Old-School Pizza And Cheesesteak Shop • Small-Town Standout
A cozy, lived-in spot known for hearty pies and cheesesteaks a few minutes south of Mantua.
Cal's II feels exactly like the kind of small-town pizza joint you hope to find on Main Street. The pizza leans toward a thicker, satisfying crust with plenty of cheese, and the cheesesteaks make it easy to feed a mixed crowd. Pair a pie with a sandwich, grab a booth, and you have an easy weeknight dinner destination.
03
Best for big groups
Guy's Pizza Co.
Downtown Kent • College-Town Slice Joint • Great For Sharing
Big, topping-heavy pizzas and creative combos popular with the Kent crowd.
Guy's Pizza Co. is built for hungry groups, with oversized pies, specialty options, and flavors that skew fun rather than fussy. It is an easy choice if you are meeting friends in Kent or need enough pizza to cover a houseful of visitors. Expect a casual, student-heavy vibe and a menu that goes well beyond plain cheese.
04
Hearty hometown chain
Gionino's Pizzeria
Ravenna Strip • Neighborhood Chain Takeout • Family Takeout Favorite
Thick, chewy crusts, lots of cheese, and big family-friendly portions.
Gionino's is a Northeast Ohio staple, and the Ravenna location is an easy option when you are already out running errands. The pizza leans rich and filling, with a crust that can handle extra toppings and extra cheese without getting soggy. Add an order of jojo potatoes and chicken and you have a full, shareable spread for a family movie night.
05
Late-night fix
Domino's Pizza
Near Kent State Campus • National Delivery Chain • Late-Night Go-To
Fast, customizable pizzas that shine when convenience matters most.
The Kent Domino's is less about ambiance and more about getting hot pizza in your hands quickly, especially later in the evening. With easy online ordering and plenty of sauce, crust, and topping options, it is a practical pick when everyone wants something slightly different. It is not the most romantic choice, but for late study sessions or last-minute cravings, it gets the job done.