01
Old-school classic
Teresa's Pizza
Dunham Road Corridor • Old-School Pizza Shop • Local Favorite
The original Teresa's serves classic Cleveland-style pies with a loyal Maple Heights following.
This is the original Teresa's location, and it still feels like a neighborhood staple where families have been ordering for decades. Expect well-loaded pizzas, sheet pies for parties, and reliable wings and sides to round out the meal. Call ahead on weekends—locals know this is one of the first places to book up on game nights.
02
Best for big groups
Georgio's Oven Fresh Pizza Co.
Broadway Avenue Strip • Oven-Baked Pizza And Wings Joint • Best For Sharing
Georgio's is known for oven-fresh pies with plenty of topping options and crowd-friendly deals.
If you’re feeding a group, Georgio’s is one of the easiest calls in Maple Heights thanks to its big pizzas and combo specials. The crust lands in that happy middle ground between soft and crisp, with generous cheese and toppings. It’s a go-to for casual get-togethers, kids’ parties, and any night you don’t feel like cooking for a crowd.
03
Hearty slice stop
Rascal House
Maple Heights Town Center • Casual College-Style Pizzeria • Best For Hearty Slices
Rascal House dishes out thick, cheesy pies and classic comfort-food sides in a no-fuss setting.
This local chain brings its trademark oversized slices and heavy-on-the-cheese pies to Maple Heights. It’s the kind of place where you can grab pizza, wings, and loaded fries in one order and everyone leaves full. Ideal when you want something a little indulgent and aren’t counting calories.
04
Fast delivery standby
Domino's Pizza
Northfield Road Corridor • National Delivery Chain • Late-Night Pick
Domino’s on Northfield Road is the reliable choice for quick delivery and customizable pies.
For nights when convenience matters more than anything else, this Domino’s is often the first number Maple Heights residents dial. The menu covers everything from thin-crust and pan pizzas to pastas, sandwiches, and desserts, with plenty of sauces and toppings to tweak your order. Online ordering and tracking make it especially handy for late-night or bad-weather cravings.
05
Deal-friendly carryout
Papa Johns Pizza
Warrensville Center Road • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Best For Deals And Carryout
Papa Johns on Warrensville Center Road is a go-to for coupon-friendly pies and quick pickup.
If you like to stack coupons and take advantage of weekly specials, this Papa Johns is worth keeping in your rotation. The pizzas skew toward a softer, doughy crust with plenty of garlic sauce on the side, plus familiar toppings and specialty pies. It’s especially convenient for quick carryout on busy weeknights when you’re driving through the Warrensville Center corridor.