01
Classic valley institution
Belleria Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Struthers • Red-Sauce Italian Pizzeria And Restaurant • Local Institution
A Mahoning Valley staple pairing thick, cheesy pizza with hearty Italian comfort food.
Belleria in Struthers is the kind of place families have been ordering from for decades, especially when cravings hit for classic, square-cut valley pizza. The crust runs on the thicker side, with plenty of cheese and a generous hand with toppings, from old-school pepperoni to sausage and peppers. With pasta, sandwiches, and salads rounding out the menu, it’s an easy all-ages choice when you want a sit-down meal or a big takeout order that everyone will recognize.
02
Best for carryout
Cocca's Pizza (Struthers)
Struthers • Neighborhood Takeout And Delivery Shop • Best For Quick Carryout
Reliable, fast, and friendly, Cocca's is a go-to for carryout pies, wings, and subs on busy weeknights.
Cocca's in Struthers leans into what it does best: solid, crowd-pleasing pizza that travels well. The crust has a light crunch, the sauce is straightforward and savory, and the toppings lineup hits all the local favorites, from cup-and-char pepperoni to loaded meat pizzas. Add in wings, breadsticks, and frequent specials, and it’s an easy stop when you’re heading home through town and want dinner ready by the time you get back to Maple Ridge.
03
Best for delivery
Ianazone's Homemade Pizza (Campbell)
Campbell • Casual Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Best For Late-Night Delivery
Campbell’s Ianazone's is a dependable choice when you want a hearty, cheesy pizza dropped right at your door.
Ianazone's in Campbell is built around delivery, making it especially handy for Maple Ridge residents who don’t feel like leaving the house. Pies come loaded, with a soft, slightly chewy crust that holds up under heavy cheese and toppings like banana peppers, sausage, or their popular pepperoni. Round out your order with jojo potatoes, wings, or a salad, and you’ve got a full game-day spread without ever starting the car.
04
Best for a night out
Avalon Downtown
Downtown Youngstown • Lively Bar-And-Grill With Specialty Pizzas • Best For A Night Out
A downtown Youngstown favorite where crisp, creative pizzas share the spotlight with a full bar and bustling game-day atmosphere.
Avalon Downtown is where you go when pizza is just part of the plan and you want some energy with your meal. The pizzas run from straightforward cheese and pepperoni to specialty combinations with fresh vegetables, premium meats, and plenty of garlic and herbs, all on a crust that leans crisp and foldable. With big TVs, a full bar, and a busy dining room on weekends, it’s a fun option when you’re making an evening of the short drive from Maple Ridge into the city.
05
Hometown legend
Wedgewood Pizza (Boardman)
Boardman • Old-School Valley Pizza Shop • Hometown Legend
A Mahoning Valley icon known for hefty cheese, bold sauce, and square-cut pies that define the local style for many residents.
Wedgewood Pizza in Boardman is often the benchmark locals use when they talk about “Valley pizza.” Expect a sturdy, medium-thick crust, a tangy, slightly sweet sauce, and serious amounts of cheese, all cut into familiar squares that are ideal for sharing. It’s a bit more of a drive from Maple Ridge than some other picks, but many locals will tell you it’s worth the extra miles when only a classic Wedgewood sheet pizza will do.