01
Best overall pick
Bruno's Pizzeria
Marblehead Village Center • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Big, foldable slices, friendly service, and fair prices make this Marblehead staple an easy go-to for pizza night.
Bruno's does the kind of straightforward, crowd-pleasing pizza that works just as well for a family feast as it does for a quick lunch between lake stops. The crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and crisp, with plenty of cheese and a generous hand on toppings. Call ahead for carryout on busy summer evenings when half the peninsula seems to have the same idea.
02
Most creative pies
Sloopy's Sports Cafe
Lakeside Marblehead Strip • Lively Sports-Bar Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups
Award-winning, generously topped pies and wall-to-wall TVs make Sloopy's the spot when you want serious pizza with a side of game-day energy.
Sloopy's is known for piling on toppings and playing with flavor combinations, so it is a smart pick when everyone at the table has a different craving. Expect a busy, noisy room when there is a big game on, along with a tap list and appetizers that make lingering easy. It is a natural stop after a day at the lake when you still have a bit of energy left and a big appetite to match.
03
Convenient carryout choice
Dave's Drive Thru
East Harbor Road Corridor • Casual Carryout And Convenience Stop • Quick Grab-And-Go
Dave's turns out surprisingly good, cheesy pies from a modest drive-thru, perfect when you're heading back from the lake or campground.
Part convenience store, part local secret, Dave's is where you grab a hot pizza without changing out of your beach clothes. The crust is straightforward, the toppings are classic, and the pies hold up well for the short drive back to a rental cottage or campsite. It is especially handy on check-in or check-out days when you want dinner handled with almost no effort.
04
Classic tavern pie
Bell Mell Tavern & Pizza
Downtown Port Clinton • Neighborhood Tavern With Pizza • Best Bar Pie
Bell Mell serves up pan-style pizzas loaded with toppings in a relaxed tavern setting that feels straight out of small-town Midwest central casting.
A short drive from Marblehead, Bell Mell is the place to go when you want a cold beer with your pizza and do not mind a little noise from the bar. The pan-style crust is sturdy enough to hold lots of cheese and toppings, and regulars are loyal to their favorite combinations. Grab a booth, feed the jukebox, and settle in for a low-key evening that feels very Port Clinton.
05
Italian night out
Ciao Bella
Catawba Island/Port Clinton Corridor • Upscale Italian Restaurant With Wood-Fired Pies • Date-Night Pizza Spot
Ciao Bella's char-kissed, wood-fired pizzas pair with wine, pasta, and a polished dining room for a more leisurely meal near the marina.
If you want pizza but also want to dress up a bit, Ciao Bella is the answer just down the road from Marblehead. The pizzas come out with blistered, chewy crusts and thoughtful toppings, and you can build a whole evening around antipasti, salads, and a bottle from the wine list. It is a comfortable choice for date night, celebrations, or when visiting friends expect something a step above takeout.