01
Best overall pick
OH Pizza & Prime
Marengo – I-71 Exit Area • Casual Pizza & Grill • Best Overall Pick
A roomy, casual spot just off the interstate where you can sit down to well-topped pies instead of settling for fast food.
OH Pizza & Prime is the place locals point travelers to when they ask for a real meal near the Marengo exit. The crust has a good chew, toppings run generous, and there are enough non-pizza options that everyone at the table stays happy. It’s an easy choice when you want a proper break from the road without driving far into town.
02
Best quick stop off I-71
Pizza To Go
Marengo – State Route 61 • Drive-Through Takeout Pizzeria • Fastest Pickup
Pickup-only pies with a handy drive-through window make this a go-to for busy locals and anyone hustling back to the highway.
Pizza To Go is built for convenience, but the pies are better than the name lets on: soft, warm crusts, a sweeter sauce, and plenty of cheese. Regulars call ahead, swing through the drive-through, and are back on the road in minutes. It’s especially handy on weeknights when you want something hot without getting out of the car.
03
Best for families
Highland Pizza & Ice Cream
Marengo – Highland School Area • Family Pizza & Ice Cream Shop • Best For Kids And Teams
A kid-friendly counter spot pairing hearty, shareable pies with soft-serve and sundaes after games or practices.
Highland Pizza & Ice Cream leans into the classic small-town combo: pizza first, then dessert. The pies are straightforward and filling, with plenty of options for picky eaters, and it’s common to see youth teams crowding in after a game. Finish with cones or a sundae and you’ve got an easy family night without leaving the neighborhood.
04
Best for game-day carryout
Donatos Pizza Sunbury
Sunbury • Crispy Thin-Crust Chain • Best For Large Group Orders
Crisp thin-crust, party-cut pies make this Sunbury Donatos a reliable choice when you’re feeding a crowd back in Marengo.
A short drive south, the Sunbury Donatos is where many Marengo families order from when they need several pizzas that will actually arrive on time. The signature thin crust holds up well on the ride home, and the edge-to-edge toppings mean every square gets something. It’s a smart pick for parties, game days, and busy weekends when delivery logistics matter as much as flavor.
05
Best nostalgic sit-down
Pizza Hut Mount Gilead
Mount Gilead • Classic Dine-In Chain Pizzeria • Best Nostalgic Option
A small-town Pizza Hut that still delivers the familiar pan pizza, wings, and booth seating many people grew up with.
Head north to Mount Gilead when you’re craving the comfort of a classic pan pizza and a red-roof-style sit-down experience. It’s the kind of place where staff recognize regulars and families linger over pitchers of soda and big pies. For Marengo locals, it’s an easy weekend outing when you want to make pizza night feel like a proper night out.