01
Best overall pick
Over the Moon Pub & Pizza
Front Street Riverfront • Lively Pub-Style Pizzeria • Best For Craft Beer And Pizza
A cozy pub atmosphere, a strong pizza lineup, and a solid tap list make this the go-to place for a fun night out in Marietta.
This spot feels like a neighborhood hangout, with plenty of locals grabbing pizza, wings, and a cold drink after work or on game nights. Specialty pies come piled high with toppings, but you can also keep it simple with a classic pepperoni or cheese. It can fill up quickly on weekends, so be ready for a bit of a wait and a lively crowd.
02
Classic slice counter
The Original Pizza Place
Downtown Shopping District • Classic Slice Shop • Iconic Local Slice
A long-running counter-service favorite, known for thin, foldable slices that are easy to grab between errands or riverfront strolls.
This is the kind of place where you walk in, point at a slice behind the glass, and have hot pizza in front of you a minute later. The crust is on the thinner side, with a nice chew that holds up well to classic toppings like sausage, mushrooms, and extra cheese. It’s an easy choice for a quick lunch, a pre-game bite, or a casual dinner without much fuss.
03
Hometown favorite
Smitty's Pizza
Pike Street Corridor • Laid-Back Carryout Spot • Best For Hearty Toppings
Generous cheese, plenty of toppings, and comfort-food sides make this a reliable stop for hungry families and game-night orders.
Smitty’s leans into big, satisfying portions, from thickly topped pies to subs, wings, and loaded fries. The pizzas are built for sharing, with plenty of cheese and a sauce that’s slightly on the sweet side. Most people call ahead and swing through for carryout, but there’s enough space inside if you want to sit down and eat without any frills.
04
Best buffet option
East of Chicago Pizza
East Side • Family-Friendly Buffet And Delivery Chain • Best For Variety
A rotating buffet of pizzas, pastas, and desserts keeps everyone happy when the group can’t agree on just one style of pie.
This East Side outpost of the regional chain is especially popular with families, teams, and big groups looking to fill up without overthinking the order. You’ll usually find several crust styles on the buffet, from thinner rounds to thicker pan pies, plus salad and a few comfort-food sides. It’s a practical, no-pressure spot where kids can try a bit of everything and adults can linger over another slice.
05
Worth the short drive
Napoli's Pizza
Belpre, Across The River • Classic Italian Pizzeria And Restaurant • Worth-The-Drive Option
An old-school Italian feel and consistently well-made pies make this nearby spot a favorite for sit-down pizza nights.
Napoli’s has a long history in the Mid-Ohio Valley, and the Belpre location draws plenty of Marietta locals willing to cross the river for dinner. The menu covers the bases with classic pizzas, pasta dishes, and shareable starters like garlic bread and salads. It’s a good choice when you want something a step up from takeout, with table service and time to settle in over a pie.