01
Best overall pick
Carlos Trattoria
Hartville • Cozy Italian Restaurant With House Pizzas • Sit-Down Favorite For Families
Carlos Trattoria is where many Hartville and Marlboro families go when they want a proper sit-down meal built around a good pizza.
The pies here lean classic—think well-seasoned sauce, plenty of cheese, and toppings that feel thoughtfully layered rather than piled on. It’s an easy choice when you’ve got a mix of pizza lovers and pasta fans at the same table. Go when you have time to linger over a basket of bread, a salad, and a hot pizza arriving on a stand.
02
Most classic Stark County pie
Kraus' Pizza
Hartville • Carryout-Focused Local Pizza Shop • Old-School Local Favorite
Kraus' Pizza is the go-to for that unmistakable Stark County style: saucy, cheesy, and built for carryout nights.
This is the spot you call when you want a no-fuss pie that tastes like hometown pizza should. The crust is sturdy enough for heavy toppings, and the sauce has a slight sweetness that keeps locals loyal. Order a couple of larges, add a side or two, and you’re set for a game night back in Marlboro.
03
Best for variety
Pisanello's Pizza
Alliance • Old-School College-Town Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups
Pisanello's in Alliance offers the kind of broad menu and flexible pizza options that make feeding a crowd easy.
Expect a classic Midwest pizzeria feel, with everything from simple cheese pies to loaded specialty combinations and thick, filling slices. It’s a handy stop if you’re in Alliance for a game or errand and need to grab enough food for a car full of people. Call ahead for multiple pizzas or a mix of pies and subs to bring back toward Marlboro.
04
Best for specialty pies
Romeo's Pizza
Hartville • Modern Ohio Pizza Chain With Creative Toppings • Good For Adventurous Eaters
Romeo's Pizza is where you go near Marlboro when you want something more inventive than pepperoni-and-cheese.
In addition to the usual line-up, Romeo’s leans into bold sauces and heavier topping combos, so it’s a smart choice when your group likes to experiment. The crust is substantial enough to handle loaded pies, from meat-heavy creations to sweeter, sauce-forward signatures. It’s a reliable option for delivery or quick pickup on the way back through Hartville.
05
Most unexpected slice
Aida's Bakery
Hartville • Bakery And Café That Also Serves Pizza • Casual Lunch Stop
Aida's Bakery might be known first for baked goods, but its pizza makes for a low-key, satisfying lunch near Marlboro.
You’ll find a relaxed, café-style atmosphere that works well when you want something lighter than a full pizzeria experience. The pizza pairs nicely with their breads and pastries, so you can grab a slice and a treat in one stop. It’s a good pick when you’re already in Hartville and want a simple, unfussy meal before heading home.