01
Closest to Marne
Plaza Pizza
North Newark • Classic Carryout Pizzeria • Go-To For Marne Delivery
A long-running local outfit that sends generously topped pies from Newark straight out to Marne.
Plaza Pizza leans into its role as the nearby standby for Marne, with straightforward, well-sauced pies and dependable delivery. The crust runs in the Ohio tavern-style lane—thin but sturdy enough for plenty of toppings. It’s the easy choice for a no-fuss Friday night when you want hot pizza at your door without overthinking it.
02
Best for big appetites
Too Talls Pizza
East Newark • Hearty Neighborhood Pizza Shop • Best For Hearty Slices
Known for loaded pies and serious cheese pull, this is the spot when you want a filling, comfort-food kind of pizza.
Too Talls specializes in substantial, topping-heavy pizzas that feel built for sharing with a hungry crowd. Expect a slightly thicker crust, lots of cheese, and classic Midwestern combinations like sausage, pepperoni, and mushrooms. It’s an easy detour on the way back to Marne when you’re coming through the east side of Newark and want leftovers for tomorrow.
03
Best for families
Christy's Pizza
Northwest Newark • Family-Friendly Pizza & Subs Counter • Family-Night Favorite
A kid-friendly staple with crowd-pleasing pizzas, subs, and breadsticks that make ordering for a group simple.
Christy’s Pizza offers a broad, family-oriented menu where everyone can find something, from basic cheese pies to specialty combinations and hot subs. The pizzas lean classic—think square-cut, thin-to-medium crust with a balance of sauce and cheese. It’s a convenient option when you’re hauling the family into town from Marne and want a relaxed, predictable meal.
04
Old-school pick
Louie's Pizza
Downtown Newark • Old-School Tavern-Style Pizzeria • Classic Downtown Staple
A downtown favorite for crisp, tavern-style pies and a no-frills, local-regulars vibe.
Louie’s leans into that old-school Ohio pizza feel, with thin, crisp crust and square-cut slices perfect for sharing around a table. The menu sticks to tried-and-true toppings, but the flavor is dialed in, especially on the pepperoni and sausage combinations. If you’re pairing a wander around the courthouse square with a casual bite before heading back to Marne, this is the stop that feels most like a local institution.
05
Best game-day spot
Don & Sue's Pizza
South Newark • Casual Bar-And-Pizza Spot • Best For Casual Meetups
Laid-back and friendly, with pizzas that fit right in with cold drinks, sports on TV, and lingering conversations.
Don & Sue’s mixes a neighborhood-bar atmosphere with reliably good pizza, making it a natural choice for game days or casual get-togethers. The pies come with a slightly thicker crust and plenty of cheese, built for sharing over a couple of rounds. It’s a relaxed place to hang out with friends from Marne when you don’t mind the short drive for a more social night out.