01
Best overall pick
Don Tomasso's Italian Kitchen
Downtown Upper Sandusky • Sit-Down Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Dine-In
A cozy Italian spot known for generous portions and reliably good, hand-tossed pies.
If you want more than just a quick slice, Don Tomasso's is the place to linger over pizza, pasta, and a basket of warm breadsticks. The crust is sturdy but still chewy, with toppings piled on in classic Midwest fashion. It’s an easy choice when you’ve got a mixed group that wants both pizza and full Italian dinners at the same table.
02
Family takeout standby
A.J.'s Heavenly Pizza
North End Upper Sandusky • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Best For Families
A go-to carryout joint with crowd-pleasing specialty pies and value-friendly family deals.
A.J.'s Heavenly Pizza is the place locals call when they need an easy dinner that still tastes homemade. The crust runs on the slightly thicker, comfort-food side, with a sweet-leaning sauce and plenty of cheese. Family specials, big sheet pizzas, and efficient service make it ideal for feeding a houseful without much planning.
03
Group-friendly value
East of Chicago Pizza
East Side Upper Sandusky • Casual Buffet-Style Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Teams
A familiar regional chain where pan pizzas, baked subs, and buffets make feeding a crowd straightforward.
East of Chicago leans into hearty, pan-style pizzas with thick, bready crusts and plenty of toppings. It’s the kind of place coaches and group leaders gravitate toward after games thanks to shareable pies and regular buffet options. If you’re coming from Marseilles with a car full of hungry kids, it’s an easy, low-fuss stop.
04
Best nearby small-town slice
Padrone's Pizza of Carey
Carey • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Worth The Drive From Marseilles
A classic Ohio carryout shop known for crispy-edged pies and solid, no-nonsense toppings.
Padrone's in Carey has the feel of a small-town standby: simple menu, friendly counter service, and pizza that tastes exactly like you hoped it would. The crust bakes up crisp on the bottom with just enough chew, making it great for pepperoni or classic deluxe orders. Call ahead from Marseilles, pick it up hot, and head home before the cheese has a chance to cool.
05
Classic Kenton pie
Michael Angelo's Pizza
Kenton • Old-School Pizza Parlor • Game Night Favorite
A long-running Kenton spot with nostalgic parlor vibes and shareable pizzas ideal for game nights.
Michael Angelo's feels like the kind of hometown pizza joint many people grew up with—nothing fussy, just well-seasoned sauce, plenty of cheese, and familiar toppings. The pies are built for sharing, whether you’re picking one up on your way back through Kenton or settling in with friends. It’s a comfortable option when you want a classic, no-surprises pizza night within a short drive of Marseilles.