01
Destination pie worth the drive
Coccia House
Near Downtown Wooster • Old-School Italian Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Classic Pies
A Wooster landmark turning out thick, cheesy pizzas that many locals consider the area standard-bearer.
If you ask around Marshallville where to go for a “real” pizza night, Coccia House is the name that comes up again and again. Expect generously topped, slightly thicker crust pies cut into squares, plus a cozy, no-frills dining room that feels like it hasn’t changed in decades. It gets busy on weekends, so calling ahead for takeout or arriving early is usually a smart move.
02
Best for feeding a crowd
Donatos Pizza
North Wooster Shopping Strip • Thin-Crust Chain Pizzeria • Best For Shareable Party Pizza
Crisp-edge thin crust and edge-to-edge toppings make this a reliable choice when you’re ordering for a group.
Donatos in Wooster is a favorite for Marshallville families planning movie nights, team parties, or casual get-togethers. The trademark thin crust holds up well under generous toppings, and the big party-size orders travel easily back to town. Online ordering is straightforward, with plenty of options for lighter or specialty pies if not everyone wants a heavy classic.
03
Go-to fast delivery option
Domino's Pizza
East Wooster • Fast-Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night Delivery
Customizable pizzas and familiar sides make this a go-to when you want something hot and fast without overthinking it.
For nights when you just need pizza to show up at the door, the Wooster Domino’s is often the easiest play from Marshallville. The menu is broad, from build-your-own pies to specialty options, chicken, and stuffed cheesy breads, so everyone can land on something they like. Order tracking and consistent timing make it especially handy on busy weeknights or after a long day at work.
04
Classic family-night choice
Pizza Hut
Cleveland Road Corridor, Wooster • Family-Friendly Chain Restaurant • Best For Sit-Down Family Dinner
Familiar pan pizzas, wings, and roomy booths make this an easy option for a relaxed meal out of the house.
The Wooster Pizza Hut is the kind of place where kids know exactly what they’re getting and parents don’t have to think too hard about the menu. Pan, hand-tossed, and stuffed-crust options cover most cravings, and the wings and breadsticks round out a table meant for sharing. It’s a practical pick when you want a low-stress sit-down dinner that’s still an upgrade from eating in the car.
05
Regional chain with local feel
Gionino's Pizzeria
Orrville • Regional Northeast Ohio Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Hearty Delivery
Known for hearty Ohio-style pies and generous combo deals that make delivery night feel like a feast.
Gionino’s has a strong following across Northeast Ohio, and the Orrville location is a popular choice for Marshallville residents who don’t mind a short drive or a delivery handoff. The crust leans hearty, with plenty of cheese and toppings that feel more small-town than big-box chain. Add in their well-known chicken and jojo potatoes, and it’s easy to turn a simple pizza order into a full family spread.