01
Best overall pick
Zontini's Pizza
Downtown Martins Ferry • Square-Pan Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Beloved for its big square trays, Zontini's is the go-to Martins Ferry pie for feeding a crowd.
Zontini's is classic Martins Ferry pizza: thick, airy crust, edge-to-edge cheese, and those massive 28-slice trays that show up at every party in town. The menu stays focused on pizza, with straightforward toppings and a style that leans hearty rather than fussy. It’s a takeout-first shop, so call ahead, grab a tray, and head home or to the riverfront for an easy local feast.
02
Best for families
DeFelice Bros. Pizza
Near Martins Ferry Riverfront • Classic Regional Pizza And Subs Shop • Family-Friendly Favorite
A regional staple, DeFelice Bros. delivers dependable pies, subs, and wings that keep both kids and adults happy.
DeFelice Bros. is the kind of place locals rely on for Friday night dinners and game-day spreads. Expect a slightly thicker, hand-tossed crust, well-browned cheese, and generous toppings that feel built for sharing. With a full menu of subs, salads, and wings alongside their pizzas, it’s an easy one-stop order for bigger families and mixed appetites.
03
Most iconic style
DiCarlo's Pizza (Wheeling)
Downtown Wheeling • Ohio Valley-Style Square Pizza Shop • Iconic Ohio Valley Slice
DiCarlo's is the definitive Ohio Valley pizza experience, with hot crust and sauce topped by cold cheese right out of the oven.
Just across the river in Wheeling, DiCarlo's is a pilgrimage spot for anyone curious about true Ohio Valley-style pizza. The crust and sauce bake first, then a flurry of cold cheese and toppings go on as it’s cut into squares, giving each bite a distinctive texture. It’s a no-frills counter-service setup, perfect for grabbing a box of squares and heading back over the bridge to Martins Ferry.
04
Best for specialty pies
Biggy's Pizza
Neighborhood Wheeling • Casual Shop With Big New York-Style Slices • Creative Pie Pick
Biggy's serves up oversized slices and creative specialty pies that feel made for sharing with friends.
Biggy's leans into New York-style inspiration, with wide, foldable slices and crust that holds up under plenty of toppings. The menu usually features loaded specialty combinations alongside build-your-own options, so everyone at the table can find something they like. It’s a relaxed, come-as-you-are kind of spot, ideal for a casual night out after crossing over from Martins Ferry.
05
Best for late-night delivery
Wheeling Pizza Express
Central Wheeling • Fast-Delivery Neighborhood Pizzeria • Late-Night Staple
Wheeling Pizza Express is the reliable choice when you want a hot pie delivered fast after most places have closed.
Wheeling Pizza Express focuses on straightforward, satisfying pies with a soft, chewy crust and classic toppings. It’s the kind of place you keep in your phone for late starts, overtime games, or nights when cooking just isn’t happening. Being only a short drive and delivery radius from Martins Ferry, it’s a practical option when local kitchens start to wind down.