01
Best overall pick
The Pizza Factory
Utica, East Of Martinsburg • Family-Run Small-Town Pizzeria • Worth-The-Drive Destination
Fresh dough, generous cheese, and a friendly Utica vibe make The Pizza Factory the go-to pie when you’re willing to drive a few extra minutes.
If you ask around Martinsburg where to head for a proper small-town pizza night, The Pizza Factory in Utica comes up fast. The crust is sturdy but not heavy, with that just-right chew that holds up to plenty of toppings. It feels like the kind of place where the staff recognizes regulars and the box on your passenger seat smells like pure Friday night.
02
Best for classic Ohio slices
Creno's Pizza
Mount Vernon, Northwest Of Martinsburg • Regional Ohio Chain With Square-Cut Pies • Best For Big Groups
Creno’s turns out big, square-cut pies that are easy to pass around a table full of family or teammates after a game.
Creno’s leans into that classic central-Ohio style: plenty of toppings, a thinner crust, and pizza cut into shareable squares. It’s the kind of place where a couple of larges and a side of wings will comfortably feed a carload of kids or a hungry crew back from Kokosing Lake. Call ahead for pickup on busy weekend nights; the locals know this is an easy win.
03
Best for crispy thin crust
Donatos Pizza
Mount Vernon Shopping Corridor • Crispy Thin-Crust Chain Pizzeria • Game-Night Staple
Donatos serves a crackly thin crust loaded edge-to-edge with toppings, perfect when you want something crisp and consistent every time.
For fans of a super-thin, almost cracker-like crust, Donatos in Mount Vernon is hard to beat. Their edge-to-edge topping style means nearly every bite has plenty of pepperoni, sausage, or veggies. It’s a favorite for game nights or casual get-togethers when you want predictable timing, online ordering, and pizza that travels well back to Martinsburg.
04
Best small-town classic
Dirko's Pizza
Fredericktown, North Of Martinsburg • Old-School Village Pizza Shop • Local Comfort-Food Favorite
Dirko’s feels like the kind of old-school village shop where a hot, cheesy pie and breadsticks can turn any weeknight into a small celebration.
Dirko’s in Fredericktown has that lived-in, no-frills charm that comes from serving the same community for years. Expect hearty, straightforward pizzas with plenty of cheese and all the familiar toppings, plus sides that taste like they came from a longtime family recipe card. It’s a nice excuse for a drive north when you want a change of scenery without leaving the comfort-food lane.
05
Most reliable last-minute option
Domino's Pizza
Mount Vernon, South Side • Fast-Delivery National Chain • Late-Night And Delivery Pick
Domino’s is the dependable choice when you need hot pizza on your doorstep in Martinsburg without much planning.
When schedules are hectic and nobody wants to cook, the Mount Vernon Domino’s is often the quickest way to get pizza to a Martinsburg address. The menu goes well beyond basic pepperoni, with specialty pies, stuffed cheesy bread, and wings that cover most cravings. It’s not the most romantic option on this list, but it’s the one you can count on when the clock is creeping past dinnertime.