01
Best overall pick
Generations Pizzeria
Downtown Wilmington • Lively Hometown Pizzeria And Bar • Local Favorite
A bustling downtown spot locals lean on for big, flavorful pies and a laid-back hangout.
If you only have time for one pizza stop near Martinsville, make it Generations. The menu leans into hearty specialty pies, generous toppings, and shareable appetizers that work just as well for a family dinner as they do for watching the game. It has that lived-in small-town feel where staff recognize regulars and first-timers get treated the same way.
02
Classic college-town slice
Pisanello's Pizza
Near Wilmington College • Old-School Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Best For Classic Carryout
A cozy, slightly retro shop turning out thick-crust, cheese-forward pies that taste like small-town Ohio.
Pisanello's is the kind of place that feels unchanged in the best possible way, with soft crusts, lots of cheese, and a menu full of dependable classics. It’s a go-to for students and locals who want a hot box to take back home or to a gathering without overthinking the order. The vibe is relaxed, prices are reasonable, and the pizza hits that comforting, familiar sweet spot.
03
Cracker-thin crowd-pleaser
Donatos Pizza
East Wilmington Along Rombach Avenue • Thin-Crust Chain With Precision-Cut Squares • Best For Sharing With A Crowd
Known for its ultra-thin crust and edge-to-edge toppings, Donatos is built for feeding a lot of people fast.
When you’re hosting a bigger crew near Martinsville, Donatos makes ordering easy with consistent pizzas and plenty of combo deals. The thin crust and square-cut slices are great for grazing, so a couple of larges can keep a table going through a whole movie or game. Add in salads and wings, and you can cover a range of tastes without leaving the Rombach Avenue strip.
04
Reliable late-night option
Domino's Pizza
Main Street Wilmington • National Delivery Chain • Late-Night Delivery Pick
Fast, predictable, and open later than most local spots, this Domino's is all about convenience.
For Martinsville residents, Domino's in Wilmington is the easy button when the craving hits after most local kitchens have closed. The menu sticks to what the chain does best: customizable pies, stuffed breads, wings, and desserts that travel well. Order ahead on your way back from town or have it delivered to keep the evening going without another trip out.
05
Family-friendly sit-down
LaRosa's Pizzeria
North Wilmington Retail Strip • Family Italian Chain With Big Menu • Best For Families And Picky Eaters
A sit-down spot where pizza shares the stage with pastas, salads, and kid-pleasing options.
LaRosa's is the place to go when some in the group want pizza and others are thinking spaghetti, hoagies, or a big salad. The dining room is casual and kid-friendly, with plenty of booths and a menu that keeps everyone occupied. It’s an easy choice after youth sports, errands on the north side of Wilmington, or when you want more of a meal out than a quick pickup box.