01
Best overall pick
Benny's Pizza
East Side Of Marysville • Lively Family Pizzeria With A Big Menu • Local Favorite For Groups
A Marysville staple known for generous pies, a busy dining room, and plenty of options beyond pizza.
Benny’s is the spot locals name first, thanks to its crowd-pleasing pizza, wings, and hearty appetizers that make it easy to feed a group. Portions are generous and the atmosphere is relaxed but energetic, so it works as well for kids’ teams as it does for casual nights with friends. Expect a short wait on busy evenings, but the steady buzz is part of the charm.
02
Best neighborhood vibe
Buckeye Family Pizzeria
South Maple Street Corridor • Cozy Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Families
A friendly, low-key spot turning out comforting, cheese-forward pies and classic sides.
Buckeye Family Pizzeria leans into its name, with a homey feel and staff who treat regulars like family. The pizza skews classic Midwestern—plenty of cheese, straightforward toppings, and crust that holds up well to carryout. It’s a solid choice when you want a relaxed sit-down meal where kids are welcome and service is unhurried but attentive.
03
Classic hometown choice
Giovanni's Pizza
East 8Th Street Corridor Near Downtown • Classic Italian-American Pizza Joint • Best For Classic Red-Sauce Comfort
Old-school style pies with a familiar red-sauce-and-cheese comfort that hits the spot on a quiet night.
Giovanni’s has the feel of a long-running hometown shop, with straightforward, satisfying pizza and a small-town pace. Toppings are traditional and the menu includes the usual suspects—subs, salads, and a few baked pasta dishes—so it’s easy to keep everyone happy. It’s a good pick when you want an unfussy, sit-down pizza dinner without the crowds.
04
Best for quick carryout
Marco's Pizza
West 5Th Street Corridor • Carryout-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Best For Weeknight Takeout
Reliable, build-your-own and specialty pies with fast service and consistent quality, ideal for busy evenings.
Marco’s is a go-to when you need dinner sorted quickly without much planning. The menu offers plenty of specialty combinations along with customizable options, plus wings and cheesy breads for a fuller spread. Online ordering and efficient pickup make it especially convenient for families shuttling between work, school, and activities.
05
Best for hearty slices
Jet's Pizza
Us-36 / Delaware Avenue Corridor • Detroit-Style And Deep-Dish Specialist • Best For Big, Indulgent Pizza Nights
Thick, crispy-edged square pies with bold toppings and plenty of cheese for a heavier, indulgent take on pizza.
Jet’s is the choice when you’re craving something substantial, especially their signature Detroit-style squares with caramelized edges. The crust is airy yet sturdy, making it a good match for loaded toppings and extra cheese. It’s primarily a carryout and delivery operation, perfect for movie nights or game days when you want pizza to feel like the main event.