01
Best overall pick
Two Cities Pizza Company
Historic Downtown Mason • Bustling New York & Chicago–Style Pizzeria • Destination For Pizza Fans And Groups
A lively downtown staple where you can choose between crackly New York slices and indulgent Chicago-style pies under the same roof.
Two Cities is the place locals recommend when you ask where to get pizza in Mason, especially if you’re entertaining out-of-town guests. The menu lets you go thin and foldable or thick and saucy, with creative specialty combinations alongside well-executed classics. Expect a crowd on weekends, but the upbeat vibe and consistent pies make it worth the wait.
02
Best for craft pizza and drinks
Mad Monks Pizza Co.
Mason Business District • New York–Style Pizzeria And Bar • Go-To For Pies With A Pint
Hand-tossed New York–style pizzas, a solid tap list, and a relaxed bar atmosphere make Mad Monks a reliable weeknight hangout.
Mad Monks leans into big, foldable slices with well-developed dough and generous toppings, ideal for sharing a couple of pies at the table. The bar setup means you can pair your pizza with craft beer or a cocktail while catching a game. It’s a comfortable, no-rush spot where locals linger over one more slice and one more round.
03
Best carryout classic
Big Dog's Pizza
Reading Road Corridor In Mason • Hearty Neighborhood Carryout Shop • Top Choice For Takeout Nights
A straightforward local joint turning out generously topped, comfort-first pies that travel well for takeout or delivery.
Big Dog’s is the kind of place people in Mason put on speed dial for busy weeknights and game days. The crust is sturdy, the toppings are plentiful, and the menu covers every crowd-pleaser from pepperoni to loaded meat specials. It’s not trying to be fancy—just reliably hot, cheesy pizza that shows up when you need it.
04
Best for families
LaRosa's Pizzeria Mason
Near Kings Mills And I-71 • Family-Friendly Cincinnati-Style Pizzeria • Easy Choice After Kings Island
A familiar regional favorite with sweet-leaning sauce, kid-friendly booths, and a broad menu beyond pizza.
LaRosa’s Mason location is a natural stop when you’re coming or going from Kings Island, with plenty of seating and a menu that works for picky eaters. The pizzas come on a thinner crust with that signature LaRosa’s sauce, and you can round out the table with pasta, wings, or salads. It’s more about convenience and comfort than cutting-edge toppings, which is exactly what many families want.
05
Best old-school vibe
Tony's Pizzeria & Aponte Catering
Residential Mason Near Community Parks • Cozy Italian-American Pizzeria • Laid-Back Local Mainstay
A long-running spot where pizza shares the stage with pastas and subs, all with a homey, old-school feel.
Tony’s feels like the kind of place that has quietly fed Mason for years, with a menu of familiar Italian-American favorites and straightforward pizzas. The pies lean comforting rather than experimental, with a focus on balance and a well-baked crust. It’s an easy pick when you want a relaxed meal and leftovers that still taste good the next day.