01
Best overall pick
Fire and Stone Pizzeria
Downtown Chillicothe • Craft Pizzeria With Creative Toppings • Best For Dine‑In And Date Night
A polished downtown pizzeria turning out thoughtfully topped pies and shareable appetizers in a cozy brick‑walled space.
If you want a night out that feels a notch above the usual takeout, Fire and Stone is the place to aim your GPS. The menu leans into inventive topping combinations and quality ingredients, so even a simple cheese pizza feels special. It is an easy pick for a relaxed date, a small celebration, or showing an out‑of‑town guest that Chillicothe's pizza game is legit.
02
Classic local chain
Cristy's Pizza
East Water Street In Chillicothe • Casual Carryout And Delivery Shop • Local Favorite For Carryout
A long‑running regional mini‑chain known for reliable, crowd‑pleasing pizzas and fast pickup just across town from Massieville.
Cristy's is the kind of place Ross County families have been dialing for years when they need pizza on the table without overthinking it. The crust is classic Midwest—sturdy enough for plenty of toppings, cut into easy‑to‑share squares. It is a smart choice when you are feeding a mix of kids and adults and want predictable, satisfying pies at fair prices.
03
Best for big groups
Giovanni's Pizza
Western Avenue In Chillicothe • Family-Friendly Pizza And Italian Spot • Best For Families And Teams
A roomy, family‑oriented spot serving generous pizzas, pasta, and salads that work well for hungry groups.
Giovanni's is built for teams rolling in after a game or families meeting up from around the county. Pizzas come loaded with toppings, and the broader menu means the non‑pizza people at your table still have options. From Massieville, it is a straightforward drive west into town, and you can usually count on plenty of seating and a relaxed, everyone‑welcome vibe.
04
Old-school local spot
Jerry's Pizza
Near Downtown Chillicothe • No-Frills Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best Value Pick
A straightforward, local pizzeria that focuses on hearty, no‑nonsense pies at wallet‑friendly prices.
Jerry's feels like the sort of place regulars have been visiting since high school, with an emphasis on familiar flavors over trends. Expect classic topping combos, plenty of cheese, and portions that do not skimp. It is a practical choice when you want to feed a few hungry people from Massieville without turning the night into a big production.
05
Chain standby
Pizza Hut
North Bridge Street Retail Strip • National Delivery And Carryout Chain • Best For Late‑Night And Large Orders
A go‑to option for familiar pies, wings, and deals, especially when you need easy online ordering and delivery toward Massieville.
Sometimes you just want exactly what you expect from a national chain, and this Pizza Hut on the main commercial drag delivers that comfort factor. The menu covers pan, hand‑tossed, and stuffed‑crust favorites along with wings and sides, which makes it simple to please a mixed crowd. For game nights, last‑minute gatherings, or late‑evening cravings in Massieville, it is one of the most convenient choices nearby.