01
Best overall pick
Smiley's Ristorante and Pizzeria
Downtown Massillon • Sit-Down Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Classic Family Favorite
A downtown staple where hearty Italian comfort food meets reliably excellent, shareable pizzas.
Smiley's combines a vintage Italian supper-club feel with a menu packed full of crowd-pleasing pies, pasta, and red-sauce classics. The pizzas lean generous on toppings and cheese, making them ideal for family dinners or lingering meals with friends. If you’re dining in, pair a specialty pie with a salad and arrive a bit early on weekends, when locals tend to fill the dining room fast.
02
Cozy downtown slice
Bella Sera Pizzeria
Downtown / Federal Ave • Casual New York-Style Pizzeria • Best For Classic Pies And Slices
A snug downtown spot turning out foldable, New York-leaning pies with a local, laid-back vibe.
Bella Sera is the kind of small pizzeria where you can smell the dough and sauce as soon as you walk in. The crust strikes a nice balance between chewy and crisp, with straightforward toppings that let the sauce and cheese do the talking. It’s a strong choice when you want a classic pepperoni or cheese pie, a quick lunch slice, or a low-key dinner before or after a game or event downtown.
03
Neighborhood staple
Jay's Pizza
West Side / 15Th St Sw • Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Go-To For Takeout Night
A long-running west-side favorite known for hearty, no-frills pizzas that travel well.
Jay's Pizza leans into what makes a takeout joint great: consistent pies, friendly service, and plenty of options for feeding a crowd. Expect a slightly thicker, sturdy crust that stands up to heavy toppings and extra cheese, making it ideal for delivery or big family orders. Locals often round out their pizza with wings or subs, so consider mixing a few sides into your order when you’re planning a casual night in.
04
Locals’ cult favorite
Marscotti's Pizza
Northwest Massillon • Family-Run Pizza And Stromboli Shop • Best For Stromboli Lovers
A family operation best known for generously stuffed stromboli and comforting, made-to-order pies.
Marscotti's is beloved for its stromboli, which come loaded with cheese and fillings and baked until the crust turns golden and blistered. The pizzas share that same homespun feel, with a flavorful sauce and a crust that’s substantial without being too heavy. It’s a smart pick when you want something a little different from standard pizza night and don’t mind driving a few extra minutes for a true local original.
05
Old-school carryout classic
Your Pizza Shop
West Lincoln Way • Classic Ohio-Style Pizza Shop • Value-Friendly Family Option
Square-cut, topping-loaded pies at down-to-earth prices from a familiar west-side counter.
Your Pizza Shop serves up the kind of square-cut, party-style pizza that Ohioans grow up on: thin yet sturdy crust, tangy sauce, and toppings spread right to the edge. Its straightforward menu and frequent deals make it easy to feed a crew without breaking the bank. Call ahead for large or customized orders, especially on game nights, when regulars tend to put the phones and ovens into overdrive.