01
Best overall pick
Jimmy Neno’s Pizzeria & Taproom
Brookfield Township, Just West Of Masury • Lively Taproom Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Pizza And Beer
A short hop from Masury, Jimmy Neno’s pairs well-made pies with a full taproom atmosphere and plenty of seating.
Tucked along Warren–Sharon Road, Jimmy Neno’s is a go-to for Masury residents who want more than a basic carryout slice. The menu leans into generously topped pizzas with a classic Mahoning Valley feel, plus a rotating craft beer lineup that makes it easy to turn dinner into a night out. It’s an easy choice when you’ve got a mixed group of pizza lovers and folks who want a good bar-style hangout.
02
Neighborhood staple
MVG Pizza
Sharon, Minutes Across The State Line • Casual Neighborhood Shop • Reliable Weeknight Takeout
MVG Pizza is a low-key Sharon standby that Masury locals tap for fast, straightforward pies and subs.
If you’re just looking for solid, no-drama pizza after work, MVG is the kind of place that ends up in your regular rotation. The crust leans toward classic American style, with enough chew to hold up to heavier toppings. Add in friendly counter service and quick turnaround times, and it’s an easy option when you’re swinging through Sharon on your way home from Masury.
03
Classic Youngstown-style pick
Cocca’s Pizza (Sharon area location)
Sharon Corridor Toward Hermitage • Youngstown-Style Square-Cut Shop • Best For Sheet Pizzas And Parties
Cocca’s brings the Mahoning Valley’s signature square-cut pizza style to the Sharon–Hermitage strip, handy for Masury gatherings.
Cocca’s is known around the region for its thick, airy crust, tangy sauce, and edge-to-edge cheese, all cut into shareable squares. It’s the kind of pizza that shows up at office lunches, birthday parties, and game-day spreads across the valley. For Masury residents, this location offers an easy way to grab a half- or full-sheet pie when you need to feed a crowd without overthinking the order.
04
For crust lovers
Wedgewood Pizza (Brookfield area delivery)
Delivered Into Brookfield And Masury • Mahoning Valley Classic Pizzeria • Regional Favorite Delivered Locally
A staple in the Youngstown area, Wedgewood’s well-browned crust and hearty toppings make it a favorite when you don’t mind a delivery fee.
Wedgewood has built a reputation across the Mahoning Valley for its crispy, almost caramelized crust and bold, slightly sweet sauce. While you won’t find a storefront in Masury itself, many locals are happy to pay for delivery when they’re craving that specific style. It’s especially popular for Friday nights when you want a ‘destination’ pizza without leaving the house.
05
Most convenient chain option
Domino’s Pizza (Brookfield)
Brookfield Center, Just Up The Road • Chain Carryout And Delivery • Best For Late-Night Convenience
The Brookfield Domino’s delivers reliably into Masury, with consistent pies and an easy online ordering routine.
While it’s a national chain, this nearby Domino’s earns its spot on the list by being one of the most convenient options for Masury addresses, especially later in the evening. The menu covers everything from classic pepperoni to thin-crust specialty pizzas and wings, which works well for mixed tastes or larger groups. When local independents are closed or slammed, this is the backup many residents quietly rely on.