01
Best overall pick
Pizzazz Pizza
Som Center Corridor • Family-Run Pizzeria And Bar • Local Institution
A lively, old-school spot doing hefty Cleveland-style pies and Italian comfort food right in the heart of Mayfield Village.
Pizzazz is the kind of place where families, teams, and longtime regulars all crowd in for crispy-edged pizzas and big plates of pasta. The crust has just enough chew to stand up to generous toppings, and the sauce leans classic, not fussy. It’s the go-to when you want a sit-down meal that still feels very much like the neighborhood’s own pizzeria.
02
Best for toppings and variety
Primoz Pizza Mayfield Heights
Mayfield Road Strip • Modern Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Best For Creative Custom Pies
A flexible, build-it-your-way shop known for specialty pies, wings, and solid vegan options along Mayfield Road.
Primoz is ideal when your group can’t agree on what to order, thanks to a long list of toppings, crust options, and plenty of non-pizza extras. Their specialty pizzas lean bold—think loaded meat combos, white pies, and veggie-forward choices. Add in one of the area’s better vegan lineups and it becomes a smart pick for mixed diets and big takeout orders.
03
Detroit-style favorite
Jet's Pizza Lyndhurst
Lyndhurst Stretch Of Mayfield Road • Detroit-Style Carryout And Delivery • Best For Thick-Crust Cravings
Chain or not, this Jet’s turns out reliably indulgent, cheesy-corner Detroit-style squares just minutes from Mayfield Village.
If you like your pizza with caramelized edges and serious cheese pull, Jet’s is a dependable move. The deep-dish squares travel well, making them a favorite for watching the game at home or feeding a crowd. Order the crust extra crispy and don’t skip the flavored crust options if you want to nudge it into full comfort-food territory.
04
Classic Cleveland-style pies
Master Pizza Mayfield Heights
Near I-271 Interchange • Award-Winning Local Chain • Best For Takeout Night
Longtime Cleveland-area favorite known for well-balanced pies with a crisp crust and generous toppings.
Master Pizza has been in the regional rotation for decades, and the Mayfield Heights shop is a workhorse for weeknight takeout. The crust is sturdy but not heavy, the sauce has a little zip, and they don’t skimp on cheese. It’s the kind of pizza that pleases both traditionalists and kids without feeling bland or forgettable.
05
Reliable game-night standby
Marco's Pizza Mayfield Heights
Residential Mayfield Heights • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Best For Big Orders On A Budget
A neighborhood workhorse turning out consistent, crowd-pleasing pies, subs, and cheesy bread for easy pickup or delivery.
Marco’s is the choice when value and speed matter as much as the pizza itself. The crust is softer and more pillowy than most local joints, which works well for loaded specialty pies and their popular cheesy bread. It’s an easy, low-stress option for kids’ parties, casual hangouts, or those nights when you just want plenty of hot pizza to appear at the door.