01
Best overall pick
Primoz Pizzeria Mayfield Heights
Central Mayfield Heights • Modern Local Pizzeria With Creative Pies • Best All-Around Choice
A local mini-chain that nails the balance of inventive toppings, solid crust, and reliable delivery.
Primoz is the place locals call when they want something a little more interesting than a basic pepperoni but still weeknight-friendly. The menu leans into creative combinations, with options for vegans and picky eaters alongside the standards. It’s equally handy for a quick carryout order or feeding a crowd during the game.
02
Classic Cleveland-style
Master Pizza Mayfield Heights
Eastgate Area • Old-School Pizza Joint • Top Pick For Classic Slices
A long-running Cleveland favorite known for sturdy crust, generous cheese, and no-nonsense pies.
If you grew up on Northeast Ohio pizza, Master Pizza will feel instantly familiar. The pies come loaded with toppings, square-cut, and built to stand up to dipping sauces and reheating. It’s a strong bet when you want straightforward, comforting pizza with a side of nostalgia.
03
Reliable chain standby
Marco's Pizza Mayfield Rd
Mayfield Rd Strip • Fast-Casual Takeout Spot • Go-To For Quick Delivery
A busy neighborhood Marco’s that turns out consistent, crowd-pleasing pies and subs.
This Mayfield Road location is all about convenience: online ordering is smooth, delivery is quick, and the pizza is exactly what you expect from Marco’s on a good night. The chewy crust and customizable toppings make it easy to keep everyone at the table happy. It’s a smart move for last-minute dinners and late study sessions.
04
Detroit-style detour
Jet's Pizza Lyndhurst
West Of Mayfield Heights In Lyndhurst • Counter-Service Detroit-Style Shop • Best For Deep-Dish Fans
Known for its thick, airy Detroit-style squares with caramelized cheese edges and plenty of sauce.
Just over the line in Lyndhurst, this Jet’s is the closest stop if you’re craving that indulgent, pan-baked style. The corner pieces are the star, with crisp edges and a satisfying crunch under all that cheese. Order ahead for pickup or delivery when you want something heavier than your usual thin crust.
05
Family tavern feel
Zeppe's Tavern & Pizzeria Mayfield
Som Center Corridor In Mayfield Village • Tavern-Style Pizzeria And Bar • Best For Groups And Game Nights
A sit-down spot where you can pair substantial pies with wings, drinks, and the game on TV.
Zeppe’s in nearby Mayfield Village works when you want more of an evening out than a delivery box. The pizza leans hearty, with thick layers of cheese and plenty of build-your-own options, plus a full lineup of wings and bar snacks. It’s an easy choice for birthday gatherings, team celebrations, or watching a big matchup with a group.