01
Best overall pick
Mama Renie's Pizza
Downtown Mcarthur • Small-Town Pizza Pub • Local Favorite
The hangout-in-town for a hearty pie, cold drink, and friendly small-town service.
Right on Main Street, Mama Renie’s feels like the village living room, with families, ball teams, and regulars sharing pizzas in cozy booths. The crust is sturdy enough for generous toppings, and classic combos like pepperoni and extra cheese hit that nostalgic pizzeria note. It’s the spot locals mention first when you ask where to grab a pizza without leaving McArthur.
02
Worth-the-drive favorite
Pizza Crossing
Downtown Logan • Bustling Hocking Hills Pizzeria • Big-Flavor Crowd-Pleaser
A Hocking Hills staple known for hefty, cheese-laden pies that are easy to share after a day on the trails.
About a short drive north in Logan, Pizza Crossing draws both locals and Hocking Hills visitors with its thick layer of cheese and generous toppings. The dining room stays busy on weekends, but the staff keeps orders moving, whether you’re grabbing a couple of larges for a cabin group or eating in. If you want a ‘make-a-meal-of-it’ style pizza with plenty of leftovers, this is the place to aim for.
03
Game-night standby
Cristy's Pizza
Logan Shopping Strip • Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Best For Feeding A Crowd
Square-cut pies, familiar toppings, and reliable delivery make Cristy’s an easy choice for group orders.
Set along Logan’s main commercial strip, Cristy’s leans into convenience without feeling generic. The pizzas come cut into party-style squares, ideal for sharing with a crowd or keeping everyone happy on movie night. With plenty of topping combos, wings, and sides, it’s a solid option when you’re staying in a rental or just want straightforward, no-fuss pizza after a drive from McArthur.
04
Old-school classic
Giovanni's Pizza
Wellston Main Drag • Classic Italian-American Pizza Joint • Best For Nostalgia
A regional favorite with a slightly sweet sauce and plenty of Ohio small-town charm.
Head south to Wellston and you’ll find Giovanni’s, a sit-down-and-stay-awhile kind of pizza place with a loyal local following. The pies lean classic—think ample pepperoni cups, plenty of cheese, and a sauce with a hint of sweetness that feels very southeast Ohio. It’s a good choice when you want pizza plus subs, salads, and the kind of laid-back service that encourages a second soda refill.
05
Reliable late-night option
Domino's Pizza
East Logan • National Delivery Chain • Late-Night Pick
Fast delivery, online deals, and build-your-own pies make Domino’s the go-to when convenience matters most.
When it’s late, the weather is bad, or you just don’t feel like driving out of McArthur, Domino’s in Logan is often the quickest way to get a hot pizza to your door or cabin. The menu is familiar—hand-tossed, thin, or pan pizzas with plenty of sauces and toppings, plus wings and stuffed cheesy bread. It’s not trying to be a destination spot, but for predictable, fast, and customizable pizza, it more than does the job.