01
Best in-village pick
Pisanello's Pizza
In-Village Mccomb • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Closest Classic Slice To The Mccomb Square
Your no-brainer choice when you want a hot, familiar pie without leaving McComb.
Pisanello's is the spot locals rely on when they want pizza night to be easy: call ahead, swing through town, and head home with a box that always tastes like Friday. The crust runs on the softer, doughier side with plenty of cheese, and the menu covers the classics plus a few loaded specialty pies. It is especially handy for feeding a team, youth group, or last-minute gathering without a long drive.
02
Best for big family orders
Heavenly Pizza
North Findlay Corridor • Faith-Based Local Pizza And Subs Shop • Best Value Pies For Big Family Orders
Generous toppings, friendly staff, and value-focused specials make this a go-to from McComb to Findlay.
Heavenly Pizza is known around Findlay for its hearty hand-tossed pies, sweet-leaning sauce, and a menu that stretches from thick, cheesy slices to subs and salads. Portions are big and prices fair, which makes it a smart move when you are feeding a crew after a game or church event. Regular specials and efficient carryout keep the wait reasonable, even on busy weekends.
03
Old-school favorite
Jac & Do's Pizza
West-Side Findlay Neighborhoods • Old-School Neighborhood Pizza Joint • Go-To Option For Late-Night Cheesy Cravings
A long-running Findlay staple with a loyal following for its crispy-edged pies and no-frills vibe.
Jac & Do's is the kind of place many Findlay and Hancock County residents grew up on, with pan and hand-tossed pizzas that hit that nostalgic, slightly greasy comfort-food note. Expect a nicely browned cheese cap, plenty of toppings, and a crust that stands up well for leftovers. It is a relaxed pick for casual nights when you are more interested in hot pizza and good company than anything fancy.
04
Best sit-down experience
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
East Findlay Retail Strip • Family-Friendly Pizza And Craft Beer Grill • Top Pick When You Want Pizza With A Sit-Down Meal
A lively option where you can pair big specialty pizzas with wings, burgers, and a solid beer list.
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill works well when part of the group wants pizza and others are eyeing burgers, salads, or wings. The pizzas lean substantial, with thicker crusts, lots of cheese, and creative topping combos that are easy to split around the table. Spacious seating, plenty of TVs, and a relaxed atmosphere make it a strong choice for watching a game or lingering over dinner after a trip into Findlay.
05
Best for thin-crust delivery
Donatos Pizza
South Findlay Commercial Area • Fast-Casual Ohio Pizza Chain Spot • Reliable Choice For Quick Game-Night Delivery
Crispy, edge-to-edge pepperoni pies and efficient delivery make this a dependable option from the south side of Findlay.
If your crew likes a thinner, crispier crust and lots of pepperoni, Donatos is an easy win within delivery range of McComb's side of Hancock County. The signature edge-to-edge topping style means every slice gets plenty of coverage, which is a crowd-pleaser for kids and adults alike. Add salads or wings to the order and you have a full spread that shows up fast on busy weeknights.