01
Best overall pick
Ianazone's Homemade Pizza
Central Mcdonald • Classic Takeout Pizzeria • Hometown Staple
The go-to McDonald pie shop for generous cheese, sturdy crust, and reliable delivery night after night.
If you ask people in McDonald where they actually order from on a busy weeknight, Ianazone's is usually the first name you hear. The pizza leans classic Mahoning Valley style: well-sauced, plenty of cheese, and a crust that holds up to extra toppings. It’s strictly a casual, grab-and-go operation, but for locals it’s hard to beat for value, consistency, and that comforting ‘home base’ feel.
02
Best for game day
Inner Circle Pizza Niles
Niles • Sports-Bar Pizza And Wings • Lively Hangout
A bustling sports-bar style spot where thick-cut pizzas share the spotlight with wings, beer, and big-screen TVs.
Just a short drive from McDonald, Inner Circle in Niles is where groups head when they want more than just takeout. The pies are hearty, with a crust that lands between pan and traditional, ideal for loading up on pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese. Add in a long bar, plenty of taps, and wall-to-wall TVs and you’ve got an easy choice for game nights and casual gatherings.
03
Most iconic nearby slice
Wedgewood Pizza Austintown
Austintown • Youngstown-Style Pizzeria • Destination Pie
A regional institution known for edge-to-edge toppings, a sweet-leaning red sauce, and crisp, addictive crust.
Wedgewood is one of those names that comes up any time Youngstown-area pizza is mentioned, and the Austintown shop is the closest pilgrimage spot from McDonald. Their trays are packed with toppings, baked to a crisp edge, and cut into squares that disappear faster than you expect. It’s worth the quick drive when you want a ‘this is what the area is known for’ experience, especially for out-of-town visitors.
04
Best sit-down Italian
Enzo's Restaurant & Pizzeria
Girard • Family Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Comfort-Food Classic
A cozy Girard standby where you can pair a well-made pizza with red-sauce Italian favorites in a sit-down setting.
Enzo's in nearby Girard feels like the kind of no-rush Italian place every small town wants. The pizza has a more traditional restaurant style—balanced sauce, nicely browned cheese, and a crust that’s substantial without being heavy. It’s a smart pick when some people at the table want pizza and others are set on pasta, chicken parm, or a big salad.
05
Best old-school tavern pie
Sunrise Inn
Downtown Warren • Tavern And Pizza House • Local Institution
A downtown Warren landmark pouring cold drinks and turning out distinctive, old-school pies that regulars swear by.
Sunrise Inn has been part of the Warren dining routine for generations, and pizza is a big part of its draw. Expect a bar-friendly crust, plenty of cheese, and classic toppings, along with specialty options that lean into local tastes. It’s the kind of place where you grab a booth, order a round, and linger over a couple of pizzas while you catch up with friends or family.