01
Classic New York–style slices
Angie's New York Style Pizzeria
Mentor-On-The-Lake Lakeshore • Bustling New York–Style Slice Shop • Local Favorite For Foldable Slices
Thin, wide slices and generous toppings make Angie’s a go-to spot when you want classic New York–style pizza close to the lake.
Angie’s feels like the neighborhood slice joint every town wishes it had, with big foldable slices and pies built for sharing. The dough leans thinner, the crust has just enough chew, and the toppings run from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty combinations. It’s a reliable stop for quick carryout on weeknights or an easy, no-fuss dinner after time on the water.
02
Old-school standby
Longo's Pizza
Central Mentor • Family-Run Neighborhood Pizzeria • Longtime Local Icon
A Mentor institution for decades, Longo’s turns out classic, square-cut pies that many locals grew up eating.
Longo’s is the kind of old-school shop where regulars are on a first-name basis with the staff and the recipes haven’t changed in generations. Expect sturdy, square-cut pizzas with a slightly thicker crust, plenty of cheese, and a tangy, straightforward red sauce. It’s the place to feed a crowd without overthinking it, whether you’re picking up a few larges or grabbing a laid-back dinner in town.
03
Best for hearty sit-down meal
Mama Roberto's Pizza & Pasta
Mentor Avenue Strip • Lively Red-Sauce Italian Restaurant • Best For Families And Big Appetites
Known for big portions and a lively dining room, Mama Roberto’s also serves hearty pizzas with plenty of old-school charm.
If you want pizza with a side of full-on Italian comfort, Mama Roberto’s is the move. The pies come with a thicker, substantial crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings piled on in true red-sauce fashion, and you can round things out with pasta, meatballs, and garlic bread. It’s a natural choice for family celebrations, team dinners, or any night when you want to linger over a pizza instead of rushing back home.
04
Game-night favorite
Gionino's Pizzeria
Lakeshore Boulevard In Mentor • Carryout Pizza And Fried Chicken Joint • Go-To For Big Orders And Sharing
Gionino’s is the place to call when you need crowd-pleasing pizza and crispy fried chicken in one delivery bag.
Mentor’s Gionino’s outpost leans into hearty, comfort-heavy pies with edge-to-edge toppings and a crust that can stand up to them. The menu is built for feeding a group, with sheet pizzas, wings, and their signature fried chicken all popular on busy weekends. It’s especially handy for game nights, kids’ parties, or any gathering where convenience and quantity matter as much as flavor.
05
Big flavor, great value
G-licious Pizza
Center Street Corridor • Casual Counter-Service Pizzeria • Value Pick For Generous Pies
G-licious delivers hefty, well-topped pizzas at friendly prices, making it a go-to for locals watching both budget and flavor.
G-licious keeps things simple: solid dough, plenty of cheese, and toppings that don’t feel skimpy, all at prices that make weeknight pizza feel like an easy decision. The vibe is straightforward and takeout-focused, with quick turnaround for call-ahead orders. It’s a smart pick when you want a couple of loaded pies without paying sit-down restaurant prices.