01
Best overall pick
Michael D's & Demario's Pizza
Whipple Ave Nw By Meyers Lake Plaza • Classic Carryout Pizzeria • Go-To Neighborhood Staple
A no-fuss takeout spot right by Meyers Lake with hearty, cheese-forward pies and all the familiar toppings.
If you want pizza without straying far from the water, this is the obvious move. The menu sticks to crowd-pleasing basics done in a comforting, old-school way, with plenty of cheese and generous toppings. It’s the kind of place locals keep on speed dial for easy weeknight dinners and game-day orders.
02
Late-night slice energy
Lindsey's Pizza
Whipple Ave Nw Strip • Casual Neighborhood Shop • Best For Big, Shareable Pies
Known for sizable, saucy pies and friendly counter service, Lindsey's feels built for hungry groups.
Lindsey's leans into classic Canton comfort pizza—plenty of sauce, plenty of cheese, and crust that holds up under the toppings. It’s a favorite for families and late-night orders when you need to feed a crowd without overthinking it. Expect a steady flow of regulars picking up boxes on their way home.
03
Canton institution
Pizza Oven
West Tusc Corridor In Canton • Hearty Hometown Pizzeria • Old-School Canton Classic
A long-running local chain famous for thickly layered cheese, pepperoni, and nostalgic takeout boxes.
Ask around and you’ll hear Pizza Oven come up again and again in Canton pizza debates. The style leans rich and satisfying, with plenty of cheese and toppings packed edge to edge. It’s ideal when you’re in the mood for a classic, slightly indulgent box of pizza to take back to the lake or your hotel.
04
Longtime local standby
Angelo's Pizza
Harrison Ave Nw Corridor • Family-Run Pie Shop • Best For Classic Toppings
A decades-old pizzeria turning out reliable, familiar pies that taste like hometown Friday nights.
Angelo's has been around long enough to feel woven into the neighborhood, and the pizza reflects that easy, lived-in comfort. Expect straightforward combinations—pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, extra cheese—done with a steady hand. It’s a smart choice when you want something everyone at the table will agree on.
05
Crust lovers’ choice
Kraus' Pizza
12Th St Nw Neighborhood • Old-School Takeout Joint • Best For Customizable Orders
A local mini-chain where the slightly crisp, flavorful crust and build-your-own options keep fans coming back.
Kraus' is all about the details, especially the crust, which has just enough bite to stand out from the crowd. With a deep roster of toppings and combos, it’s easy to tailor a few pies to different tastes in your group. Call ahead, pick up a stack of boxes, and you’re set for a relaxed night in around Meyers Lake.