01
Best overall pick
Domino's Pizza
Van Wert – South Shannon Street Corridor • Fast-Casual Delivery And Carryout Shop • Reliable All-Rounder
Your go-to when you want a customizable pie delivered fast to anywhere around Middle Point and Van Wert.
Domino's in Van Wert is often the first call for Middle Point families on busy nights, with quick delivery and consistent pies. The menu is broad enough that everyone can find something, from thin-crust pepperoni to specialty chicken and stuffed cheesy bread. It’s a practical, no-fuss option when convenience matters as much as the pizza itself.
02
Best for dine-in nostalgia
Pizza Hut
Van Wert – East Side Retail Strip • Family-Friendly Sit-Down Pizzeria • Best For Families
Classic pan pizzas, roomy booths, and big pitchers of soda make this a laid-back choice for family dinners.
The Van Wert Pizza Hut leans into that old-school pizza-parlor vibe with plenty of seating and a familiar menu. The signature pan crust, loaded with toppings and just enough buttery crispness, hits the spot after ball games or school events. It’s an easy meet-up point if you’re gathering friends or family from both Middle Point and town.
03
Best quick-stop value
Little Caesars Pizza
Van Wert – Fox Road Area • Takeout-Focused Value Pizza Shop • Budget-Friendly Pick
Hot-N-Ready pies make this the fastest way to feed a crowd on the way home from Van Wert.
Little Caesars in Van Wert is all about speed and value, which Middle Point locals appreciate on hectic weeknights. Walk in, grab a Hot-N-Ready pepperoni or cheese, and you’re back on the road in minutes. The simple menu and low prices make it a smart choice for youth groups, casual hangouts, or last-minute pizza cravings.
04
Best loaded local-style pie
Fat Jack's Pizza
Lima – North Side • Hearty Midwest-Style Pizzeria • Best For Serious Toppings
A regional favorite known for generously topped pizzas that feel tailor-made for game-day sharing.
Fat Jack's in Lima is worth the slightly longer drive when you want a more indulgent pizza night. The crust is sturdy enough to hold a serious layer of cheese and toppings, and their specialty pies are built with a local crowd in mind. Call ahead for carryout on weekends, when orders from nearby small towns like Middle Point tend to spike.
05
Best sit-down night out
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
Lima – West Market Street Corridor • Lively Pizza-And-Grill Restaurant • Group-Friendly Hangout
A spacious spot pairing big specialty pizzas with a full grill menu and a solid beer list.
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill in Lima is a go-to when you want more of an outing than a simple pickup order. Their house pizzas come in generous sizes, with creative topping combinations and a crust that stays crisp under the cheese. With plenty of TVs, taps, and non-pizza options, it works well for mixed groups driving in from Middle Point and surrounding towns.