01
Best overall pick
Kraus' Pizza (Middlebranch)
Middlebranch Avenue Ne • Classic Local Carryout Shop • Local Favorite
A Stark County staple, this Middlebranch Avenue outpost turns out thick, cheese-heavy pies that define hometown pizza for many locals.[1][2]
Set right on Middlebranch Avenue NE, this Kraus' location is the default choice when nearby neighborhoods need an easy, satisfying pizza night without driving into town.[1] Part of a long-running local chain celebrated county-wide, it leans into hearty, cheese-forward pies and square-cut slices that feel comfortably old-school in the best way.[2]
02
Canton institution
Pizza Oven (Lesh Street)
Northeast Canton • Old-School Canton Pizzeria • Go-To For Big Orders
Family-owned since 1956, Pizza Oven’s Lesh Street shop is a short drive from Middlebranch and a standby for feeding a crowd with classic Canton-style pies.[3]
Pizza Oven has been a Stark County favorite for decades, and the Lesh Street location keeps that tradition going with straightforward, well-topped pizzas and familiar flavors.[3] With multiple locations across the county, locals know exactly what they’re getting here: consistent pies, generous portions, and an easy option when you’re ordering for a team, party, or big family dinner.[3]
03
Best delivery standby
Gionino's Pizzeria
North Canton • Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Reliable Weeknight Option
Gionino's is a Canton-area regular on local pizza roundups, making it a dependable choice when you want solid, no-fuss delivery from near Middlebranch.[7]
Appearing on lists of Canton-area pizza favorites, Gionino's draws steady praise from diners who want straightforward, satisfying pies without a lot of frills.[7] From Middlebranch, the nearby North Canton and Canton locations make it an easy call for weeknight delivery, especially when you’re mixing pizza with wings and other shareable sides.[7]
04
Most creative pies
Bella's Pizzeria
East Of Middlebranch • Casual Spot With Inventive Toppings • Best For Flavor Variety
Bella's puts a creative spin on pizza, pairing classic pies with specialty flavors and standout wings like their Whiskey Buffalo-sauce creations.[5]
Known for a wide-ranging menu, Bella's Pizzeria treats pizza as a canvas, backing up the basics with more adventurous combinations and sauces.[5] Their famously creative pies and wings—especially anything built around the house Whiskey Buffalo sauce—make it a fun option when your group wants something beyond the standard pepperoni-and-cheese routine.[5]
05
Classic Italian-American feel
Italo's Pizza
Market Avenue Corridor • Traditional Takeout And Dine-In Pizzeria • Best For Classic Red-Sauce Cravings
Serving the area since the 1960s, Italo's leans into a traditional pizza-and-red-sauce vibe that’s comfortingly familiar to Stark County locals.[6]
Italo's has been part of the local pizza conversation since 1966, building a following on its signature sauces and consistently made pies across multiple area locations.[6] From Middlebranch, the Market Avenue corridor is an easy hop for a box of classic pizza or a casual sit-down meal that feels like the kind of Italian-American spot many grew up with.[6]