01
Best overall pick
Capri Pizza
Near Middleburg Town Square • New York–Style Slice Shop • Best For Big Slices
Huge foldable slices and party-sized pies make Capri a go-to when you want classic New York–style pizza in Middleburg Heights.
Tucked next to the Regal Middleburg Town Square cinema, Capri feels like a true slice joint, with display cases full of oversized pies ready to reheat by the slice. The crust leans thin with a pleasant chew, the cheese is generous, and toppings run from simple pepperoni to loaded everything pies. It’s an easy choice for a quick lunch, a pre-movie slice, or a no-fuss takeout night.
02
Classic family spot
Santo's Pizza & Pasta
Pearl Road Strip • Family-Run Italian Restaurant • Best For Old-School Charm
Santo’s serves pizza the old-fashioned way, alongside heaping plates of pasta and red-sauce classics in a warm, family-run setting.
A Middleburg Heights staple for decades, Santo’s is the kind of place where the staff remembers regulars and the pizza tastes like it came from a well-seasoned hometown oven. Pies are sturdy and comforting, with a slightly thicker crust that stands up well to extra cheese and classic toppings. Settle into a booth for a leisurely meal or grab a couple of pies and a pan of pasta for an easy family dinner at home.
03
Wood-fired standout
The Brick Oven Italian Restaurant
Smith Road Business District • Wood-Fired Brick-Oven Spot • Best For Date Night
The Brick Oven turns out blistered, smoky-crusted pizzas from twin wood-fired ovens in a cozy, sit-down setting.
Here the pizza is all about the crust: lightly charred bubbles, a tender center, and just enough smoke from the brick ovens to make each bite memorable. Toppings skew a bit more artisan, with combinations that go beyond basic pepperoni without feeling fussy. Pair a pie with a salad and a glass of wine, and you have one of the better casual date-night options in Middleburg Heights.
04
Neighborhood favorite
Antonio's Pizzeria LoSchiavo
West Bagley And I-71 Area • Neighborhood Delivery Pizzeria • Best For Delivery
Antonio’s offers a big menu of classic and specialty pizzas with the kind of consistent delivery locals lean on week after week.
This locally grown mini-chain has a strong Middleburg Heights outpost, turning out pizzas with a slightly thicker, golden-brown crust that travels well. The menu leans into hearty combinations—think multi-meat pies, loaded veggie options, and white pizzas—along with wings, subs, and salads for rounding out an order. It’s the place you call when you want reliable, hot pizza on the table with minimal effort.
05
Hearty takeout choice
Geppetto's Pizza & Ribs
West 130Th Street Corridor • Carryout Pizza And Ribs Joint • Best For Game-Day Spreads
Geppetto’s is built for feeding a crowd, with square-cut pizzas, ribs, and wings all sharing the spotlight.
A longtime local name, Geppetto’s leans into comfort food with pizzas that are generously topped and often cut party-style into squares—ideal for sharing around a coffee table. The ability to add racks of ribs, saucy wings, and other sides makes it especially handy for game days or casual get-togethers. Order ahead, swing by for carryout, and you can easily cater a small gathering without breaking the bank.