01
Best overall pick
Zeppe's Pizzeria
In The Village • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Zeppe’s Pizzeria is the go-to spot in Middlefield when you want a classic, generously topped pizza without leaving the village.
This is the place many locals name first when you ask where to grab a pie in Middlefield. The crust is sturdy enough to hold plenty of toppings, but still has a satisfying chew, and the menu runs from basic cheese to loaded specialty pizzas. It’s an easy choice for casual weeknight dinners or a quick takeout order on your way home.
02
Best for a sit-down dinner
Vinny's
Center Of Middlefield • Cozy Italian Restaurant With Pizza • Best For Families
Vinny’s serves pizza alongside hearty Italian comfort food in a warm, family-friendly dining room.
If you want more than just a slice and a paper plate, Vinny’s feels like a proper night out without being fussy. Their pizzas come with a softer, doughy crust and plenty of cheese, and you can round out the meal with pasta, salads, and those garlic rolls regulars rave about. It’s a solid pick for families or anyone lingering over dinner with a group.
03
Best fast-delivery option
Domino's Pizza
West High Street Corridor • National Delivery Chain • Reliable Late-Night Option
Domino’s in Middlefield is the dependable choice when you want customizable pizza delivered fast.
This location runs like a well-oiled machine, with consistent timing and pizzas that arrive hot and made to order. The menu lets you tweak crust styles, sauces, and toppings, so everyone can get exactly what they want, from thin-crust veggie pies to hearty meat combos. It’s especially handy for game nights, last-minute gatherings, or when you simply don’t feel like leaving the couch.
04
Best for shareable deals
Pizza Hut
East High Street Strip • Family-Friendly Chain Restaurant • Best For Takeout Specials
Pizza Hut on East High Street is a solid pick when you’re feeding a crowd and watching the budget.
Here, it’s all about familiar pan pizzas, stuffed crusts, and bundle deals that make it easy to cover a whole group. The crust is thicker and buttery, great if you like a more indulgent, comfort-food style pie. It’s practical for kids’ sleepovers, casual team parties, or any evening when value matters as much as variety.
05
Worth the short drive
Capps Pizza
Downtown Burton • Small-Town Carryout Pizza Shop • Best Nearby Detour
Capps Pizza in nearby Burton rewards the short drive from Middlefield with hearty, old-school pies.
This spot feels exactly like the kind of neighborhood pizza joint you hope to find in a small Ohio town. The crust lands right between thin and thick, with well-seasoned sauce and toppings that are piled on generously. If you’re already heading toward Burton or just want to mix up your usual Middlefield routine, Capps is an easy, satisfying detour.