01
Destination pie worth the drive
Park Street Pizza
Sugarcreek • Craft Pizza And Wings Spot • Best For Ingredient-Focused Pies
A polished but relaxed Sugarcreek staple known for inventive toppings, quality ingredients, and consistently good crust.
If you are willing to drive a bit for standout pizza, Park Street Pizza is the place that locals point to first. The crust has enough chew to stand up to generous toppings, and the menu leans into creative combos alongside the usual favorites. It works just as well for a casual date night as it does for a family dinner after a day of exploring Amish Country.
02
Reliable hometown chain
Gionino's Pizzeria
New Philadelphia • Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Weeknight Standby
A go-to for thick cheese coverage, hearty toppings, and easy carryout when you just want a classic Ohio-style pie.
Gionino's in New Philadelphia feels like the definition of a local standby: you call, you pick up, you know exactly what you are getting. The pizzas are generously topped, with a slightly thicker crust and plenty of cheese baked to a golden edge. Add in their well-known fried chicken and jojo potatoes and you have an easy fix for feeding a hungry crew back in Midvale.
03
Old-school slice shop
Zifer's Mary Pizza Shop
New Philadelphia • Old-School Local Pizza Parlor • Best For Nostalgic Flavors
A no-frills, long-running shop serving straightforward pizzas that taste like small-town Friday nights.
Zifer's Mary Pizza Shop is the kind of place that shows up in local stories about growing up in New Philadelphia. The atmosphere is simple and the focus is firmly on the pizza: slightly crisp crust, balanced sauce, and toppings that lean classic rather than trendy. It is a strong pick when you want something that feels familiar and unfussy after a game or a long workday.
04
Neighborhood crowd-pleaser
Your Pizza Shop
New Philadelphia • Casual Neighborhood Pizza Shop • Best For Families
A friendly New Philadelphia staple with crowd-pleasing pies, wings, and subs that work for mixed tastes and picky eaters.
Your Pizza Shop offers the kind of broad menu that makes group ordering easy, with pizzas, subs, wings, and salads all sharing the spotlight. The pizza leans classic Ohio style, with a slightly thicker crust and sauce that is more savory than sweet. It is an especially good option for families from the Midvale area looking for a simple, everyone-is-happy dinner without a long drive.
05
Buffet-style comfort pick
East of Chicago Pizza
Uhrichsville • Casual Chain Pizzeria • Best For Variety And Value
A convenient Uhrichsville option offering multiple crust styles, lots of toppings, and good value for feeding a group.
East of Chicago in Uhrichsville is close enough to Midvale to make it a practical choice when you need pizza fast and in quantity. The menu lets you choose from pan, thin, or traditional crusts, plus hearty specialty pies and breadsticks that disappear quickly from the box. It is an easy answer for team parties, movie nights, or any time you are ordering for a mix of appetites.