01
Best overall pick
Cappy's Pizza - London
London • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Hearty Pies
A long-running London staple serving generous, straightforward pies that taste like small-town Ohio in a box.
If you want that unmistakable local-parlor feel, Cappy's in London is the place most nearby residents point you to first. The crust leans toward soft and chewy, with plenty of cheese and toppings that feel more old-school than trendy. It is an easy choice when you want a hearty pizza night before or after hopping back on I-71.
02
Best for crispy thin crust
Donatos Pizza - London
East London • Thin-Crust Ohio Chain • Best For Edge-To-Edge Toppings
This London outpost of Ohio-based Donatos is all about a crackery thin crust and toppings spread right to the edge.
Donatos in London is a reliable stop when you want something a little lighter and crispier than typical delivery pizza. The trademark thin crust makes each square-cut piece mostly about the toppings, which arrive well-distributed and nicely browned. It works especially well for mixed groups where some people want classic pepperoni while others lean toward specialty combos.
03
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza - Washington Court House
Washington Court House • Fast-Delivery National Chain • Go-To For Quick, Customizable Pies
Domino's in Washington Court House is the closest bet for quick, customizable pizza runs and reliable late-night delivery near Midway.
When timing matters more than atmosphere, the Washington Court House Domino's delivers predictable pies fast. The menu runs from classic hand-tossed to pan and thin crust, plus wings, pastas, and sandwiches to round out a bigger order. It is a smart option if you are staying nearby and want dinner to show up at the door without much planning.
04
Best for feeding a crowd
Donatos Pizza - Washington Court House
Washington Court House Retail Strip • Casual Carryout And Delivery Spot • Great For Sharing Big Orders
This Donatos location in Washington Court House is built for big, shareable orders with plenty of square-cut slices to go around.
If you are gathering family or friends near Washington Court House, this Donatos makes it easy to feed a crowd without overthinking it. Large pizzas come cut into lots of small squares, ideal for grazing at game nights, kids' parties, or post-tournament dinners. Add in salads and side dishes, and you can cover most tastes with a single pickup stop.
05
Best for thick, cheesy crust
Jet's Pizza - Grove City
Downtown Grove City • Detroit-Style Square Pizza Shop • Indulgent Comfort-Pizza Pick
Jet's in Grove City is worth the extra drive from Midway for its thick, airy Detroit-style squares with caramelized cheesy edges.
When you are in the mood for something richer than standard delivery pizza, Jet's deep-dish style is a satisfying detour. The crust is thick yet surprisingly light, with pools of cheese and sauce running right to the high, crunchy edges. Pair a specialty square pie with their trademark flavored crust options and you have a road-trip-worthy comfort meal.