01
Best overall pick
Countryside Pizza & Drive Thru
Just Outside Mifflin Village • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Rural, unpretentious, and exactly where locals go when they want a hearty, no-fuss pizza close to home.
This little spot punches above its weight with generously topped pies, baked subs, and all the classics from pepperoni to a loaded deluxe. The crust leans soft and chewy, soaking up plenty of sauce and cheese, and the Hawaiian is a quiet favorite among regulars. The handy drive-thru window makes it easy to grab dinner on the way back from the lake or a country drive.
02
Best for big appetites
Gionino's Pizzeria
North Toward Ashland • Regional Ohio Pizza Chain • Great For Sharing
Hearty, square-cut pizzas and classic sides that work well for feeding a hungry crowd without overthinking it.
Gionino's is known for its sturdy crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and slightly zesty sauce that stands up well to heavier combinations. Many locals pair their pizza with broasted chicken and jojo potatoes, turning a simple order into a full family meal. It is a practical choice when you want one call to cover pizza night for a bigger group near Mifflin.
03
Best for variety
East of Chicago Pizza
Ashland East Side • Thick-Crust And Specialty Pizza Chain • Good For Groups With Mixed Tastes
A flexible pick where pan, thin, and specialty pies keep everyone at the table reasonably happy.
East of Chicago leans into its pan and deep-dish styles, with a pillowy crust and plenty of cheese that feels built for comfort-food cravings. The menu runs wide, from loaded meat combos to taco and chicken-bacon-ranch pizzas, plus a few dessert options for anyone with a sweet tooth. It is an easy, middle-of-the-road choice when your crew cannot agree on just one style of pie.
04
Best casual night out
Two Cousins Pizza & Pub
Downtown Mansfield • Neighborhood Pizza Pub • Good For Lingering
Hand-tossed pies, cold drinks, and a laid-back room that feels right for watching a game or catching up with friends.
Two Cousins has more of a sit-down pub feel than a quick counter joint, with pizzas that arrive hot, slightly blistered at the edges, and generously topped. The menu usually stretches to wings, subs, and bar snacks, so it works well when not everyone at the table is locked in on pizza. Plan on a bit of a drive from Mifflin, but it is a nice change of pace when you want to make an evening of it.
05
Best for delivery
Marco's Pizza
Southwest Toward Mansfield • Delivery-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Reliable Standby
A consistent go-to for delivery or carryout when you want familiar, customizable pies and sides.
Marco's leans on a slightly chewy, flavorful crust and a sauce that is a touch sweeter than most, which works well with classic pepperoni or sausage orders. The menu makes it easy to mix and match pizzas, cheesy bread, and wings, so you can cover a movie night or cabin weekend with one run. It is not the most adventurous pick near Mifflin, but it is reliably fast and straightforward when convenience matters most.