01
Best overall pick
A.J.'s Heavenly Pizza
Ottawa – Main Street Corridor • Classic Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Carryout
A.J.'s Heavenly Pizza is the go-to spot in Ottawa when you just want a really solid, well-made pie.
Crust, sauce, and cheese are all dialed in here, with a balance that feels more old-school than chain. Toppings are generous without being overdone, so even a basic pepperoni or cheese pizza tastes like it got real attention. Call ahead on busy nights—locals know this is the dependable option when feeding a family or a whole ball team.
02
Best for big groups
Padrone's Pizza
Ottawa – East Side • Casual Pizza And Subs Shop • Go-To For Team Orders
Padrone's Pizza is where area coaches, farmers, and families turn when they need a lot of pizza fast without skimping on flavor.
Big, shareable pies and crowd-pleasing toppings make this an easy choice when you’re ordering for a group. The menu stretches beyond pizza into subs, breadsticks, and wings, so everyone can find something. It’s not fancy, but the friendly service and steady quality keep it in regular rotation for Miller City folks heading into Ottawa.
03
Best pizza-and-wings combo
Hillbilly's Pizza & Wings
Ottawa – West Side • Laid-Back Pizza And Wings Joint • Game-Night Pick
Hillbilly's Pizza & Wings is a favorite when you want a saucy wing order alongside a hearty, flavorful pizza.
Pies here tend to be hearty and topping-heavy, with crisped edges and plenty of cheese—perfect for sharing during a game or movie night. The wings menu has enough sauces and rubs to keep repeat visits interesting. It’s a casual, no-frills kind of place, but that’s exactly what makes it feel like a small-town staple.
04
Worth-the-drive specialty pies
Fat Jack's Pizza
Lima – North End • Hearty Specialty-Pie Shop • Best For Loaded Specialty Pizzas
Fat Jack's Pizza in Lima rewards the extra drive from Miller City with over-the-top specialty pizzas and serious portions.
This is where you go when you want more than a basic pepperoni—think meat-loaded pies, cheesy bread, and thick, satisfying slices. The crust has a pleasant chew and stands up well to heavy toppings, so nothing turns soggy on the ride home. It’s a smart choice for a weekend pizza night when you’re already heading toward Lima for errands or a game.
05
Best sit-down experience
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
Findlay – Tiffin Avenue Strip • Lively Pizza And Grill Restaurant • Family Dinner Pick
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill in Findlay pairs standout pizza with a full menu and a busy, family-friendly dining room.
Pizzas come in a range of styles and topping combos, from simple cheese for the kids to loaded specialty pies for the adults. With burgers, pastas, and appetizers on the menu, it’s easy to turn a pizza craving into a full sit-down meal. If you’re already in Findlay shopping or passing through, this is an easy, satisfying stop that still feels like a step up from a quick slice.