01
Best overall pick
Table Rock Brick Oven Pizza
Berlin East Strip • Brick-Oven Pizzeria • Destination Brick-Oven Spot
New York–style pies fired in a brick oven make this the area’s go-to when you want a sit-down pizza night with a little extra flair.
Set along East Main on the way into Berlin, Table Rock leans into a crisp, slightly chewy crust that really benefits from the brick-oven heat. Toppings lean classic but are thoughtfully balanced, and the menu has enough salads and sides to keep everyone at the table happy. It’s the place locals suggest when visitors say they’re willing to drive a few minutes for the best pizza around.
02
Best for big groups
Fox's Pizza Den
South Washington Street Corridor • Neighborhood Pizza & Sub Shop • Laid-Back Hangout
A relaxed local branch of the Fox’s chain turning out hefty pies, stromboli, and wedges that work well for sharing.
Fox’s is the kind of place you call when the whole crew ends up at your house and everyone’s suddenly hungry. The crust is soft and sturdy, built to hold generous toppings and extra cheese, and the menu runs deep with subs, wings, and shareable trays. It’s popular with teams and families because you can feed a crowd without overthinking it.
03
Best for families
East of Chicago Pizza
Village Center • Buffet-Style Family Pizzeria • Family Crowd-Pleaser
Known for its thick, bready crust and buffet nights, this spot is all about easy, no-fuss pizza dinners.
East of Chicago leans into comfort food: thick pan crusts, plenty of cheese, and straightforward topping combos everyone recognizes. On busy evenings the buffet lets kids try a bit of everything while adults can stick to their favorites. It’s an easy choice when you want pizza night to feel casual and kid-friendly, with no one arguing over which style to order.
04
Quick comfort pick
Pizza Hut
Highway 62 And 83 Junction • Chain Delivery & Carryout • Fast, Predictable Fix
The Millersburg outpost of the national chain delivers the familiar pan, hand-tossed, and stuffed-crust pizzas you already know.
Sitting just off the main highway, this Pizza Hut stays busy with carryout and delivery orders from around the village. The menu is exactly what you’d expect—classic specialty pies, breadsticks, wings, and a few pastas—making it a reliable backup when other spots are packed or closed. Locals lean on it for last-minute game-night orders and late errands that end with hot pizza in the car on the way home.
05
Worth the short drive
Charm Pizza Co.
Charm Village • Country-Town Pizzeria • Scenic Countryside Outing
A small, homey shop in nearby Charm that pairs simple, well-made pies with a slower, rural pace.
Charm Pizza Co. feels like a classic small-town stop—nothing fussy, just friendly service and pizza that tastes like it was made for locals first. The crust lands in that sweet spot between thin and thick, with toppings that skew traditional and portions that are more generous than the prices suggest. Add in the drive through Amish farm country and it becomes an easy, low-key outing when you want pizza and a change of scenery from the village.