01
Best overall pick
Lakebound Pizza
Downtown Millersport • Lakeside Craft Pizzeria • Local Favorite
House-made crusts, creative toppings, and a friendly small-town vibe make Lakebound feel like Millersport’s go-to pie shop.
Set just off the main drag in Millersport, Lakebound turns out crisp-edged pizzas with thoughtful topping combos and plenty of cheese. It’s the rare place where a classic pepperoni is as good as the specialty pies, and the staff will happily walk you through the menu. If you only have one pizza night near Buckeye Lake, start here.
02
Best lakeside stop
Pizza Cottage (Buckeye Lake)
Buckeye Lake Waterfront • Family-Friendly Local Chain • Best For Groups
A roomy, casual spot with big pizzas, loaded toppings, and a crowd-pleasing menu ideal for lake days and big tables.
Pizza Cottage is a Buckeye Lake staple, especially when you’re coming off the water and everyone is hungry at once. The pies run generous on both size and toppings, and there are plenty of shareable sides to round out the table. It’s an easy choice for families, teams, or any group that needs reliable, familiar pizza fast.
03
Crispy-Edge Classic
Donatos Pizza (Hebron Road)
Hebron / Buckeye Lake Strip • Thin-Crust Chain Pizzeria • Game-Night Standby
Known for its ultra-thin crust and edge-to-edge toppings, this Donatos is a go-to for takeout on busy nights.
Just a short drive from Millersport, the Hebron Road Donatos leans into its signature Columbus-style thin crust and neatly arranged toppings. Pizzas travel well, which makes it a smart choice when you’re feeding a crew back at a campsite or rental. Order ahead, grab it on your way through the strip, and you’re set for the evening.
04
Small-town favorite
Creno's Pizza (Baltimore)
Downtown Baltimore • Classic Small-Town Pizza Parlor • Best For Carryout From Baltimore
Creno’s does hearty, saucy pies and subs from a no-frills storefront that Baltimore locals treat like a weekly ritual.
In nearby Baltimore, Creno’s feels like the kind of pizza place every small town needs: friendly, straightforward, and consistent. The crust is a bit thicker and chewier, with plenty of sauce and cheese, and the menu branches into stromboli and subs for variety. It’s ideal when you’re passing through town and want a hot box of comfort to take home.
05
Value pick
Christy’s Pizza (Baltimore)
East Baltimore • Old-School Regional Pizza Chain • Budget-Friendly Family Option
Christy’s serves straightforward, well-priced pies that hit the spot when you’re feeding a family without overthinking it.
This long-running regional chain leans into familiar flavors: classic crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings you can mix and match without surprise. The Baltimore shop is geared toward carryout and delivery, making it a practical option when you’re staying on the east side of Millersport or commuting along Route 158. It’s the kind of place locals keep in their back pocket for weeknight dinners and kids’ parties.