01
Best overall pick
Plus 1 Pizza
Woodsfield Main Street • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Foldable, cheesy pies and friendly service make Plus 1 Pizza an easy go-to from Miltonsburg.
Locals head to Plus 1 Pizza when they want a familiar, done-right pie without leaving Monroe County. The crust is sturdy enough for extra toppings, and the specialty combinations are generous without feeling overdone. It’s a practical choice for weeknight carryout or a simple sit-down meal before heading back along the winding county roads.
02
Family night standby
Pizza Hut
Woodsfield Shopping Strip • National Chain With Dine-In • Best For Families
Woodsfield’s Pizza Hut delivers the familiar pan pizzas and roomy booths that make family outings easy.
If you’re traveling with kids or want something predictable, the Woodsfield Pizza Hut checks all the boxes. Classic pan, hand-tossed, and stuffed-crust pies are backed up by wings and pasta, so everyone can find something they like. The relaxed dining room works well after a ballgame or for a quick lunch between errands in town.
03
Hearty, loaded pies
Giovanni's Pizza
Barnesville • Italian-American Pizza Shop • Best For Big Appetites
Giovanni’s in Barnesville piles on toppings and cheese, ideal when you’re craving a generously loaded pizza.
Giovanni’s leans into old-school Italian-American comfort, with thick layers of cheese and toppings that run right to the edge. The menu typically stretches beyond pizza to subs, pasta, and salads, making it an easy one-stop order for a hungry group. It’s a smart pick when you don’t mind the slightly longer drive for a more indulgent spread.
04
Party-size specialist
Fox's Pizza Den
East Barnesville • Casual Pizza And Hoagie Shop • Best For Groups
Fox’s Pizza Den is known for its big-party pies and hoagies that can easily feed a crowd coming from the Miltonsburg area.
This spot is a go-to when you need to cover a lot of plates—think team parties, family gatherings, or weekend get-togethers. The menu features large and extra-large pizzas, along with strombolis and hoagies that travel well back to the village. Order ahead on busy nights, as their crowd-friendly sizes are popular across the Barnesville area.
05
Fast delivery option
Domino's Pizza
Barnesville By The Highway • Delivery-Focused Chain • Best For Late-Night Cravings
Domino’s in Barnesville offers quick-turn pizzas, sandwiches, and cheesy breads when convenience matters most.
For those evenings when you’d rather not linger in town, Domino’s is all about speed and consistency. The online ordering and efficient pickup make it easy to swing through Barnesville, grab your order, and head back toward Miltonsburg. It’s also handy if you like to customize crusts, sauces, and toppings down to the last detail.