01
Coziest local slice
Susie Q's Pizza and Subs
New Cumberland, Just East Of Mineral City • Tiny Family-Run Pizza And Subs Shop • Local Favorite
A humble roadside spot turning out generously topped pizzas and subs just a few minutes from Mineral City.
If you want something that feels truly local, Susie Q’s is the place people send you first. The crust is on the hearty side, loaded with cheese and toppings, and the subs are a solid backup when not everyone in the car wants pizza. Call ahead, pick up your pies, and you’re back on the road to the lake or home in no time.
02
Worth-the-drive destination
Park Street Pizza
Sugarcreek Village Center • Farm-To-Table Pizzeria With Craft Toppings • Best For Ingredients Lovers
A destination pizzeria known for high-quality ingredients, inventive toppings, and a polished small-town vibe.
Park Street Pizza is the spot locals mention when they’re willing to drive a little farther for something special. Expect thoughtfully sourced toppings, from pepperoni with real snap to seasonal veggies, on a crust that hits the balance of chew and crisp. It’s an easy choice for a night out when you want pizza to feel like an occasion instead of just takeout.
03
Late-night standby
Domino's Pizza
New Philadelphia Commercial Strip • National Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night Delivery
Reliable, quick-turnaround pizza and sides when you want something hot delivered without overthinking it.
New Philadelphia’s Domino’s is the go-to when you’re back from the lake late, the kids are hungry, and you need pizza fast. The menu is familiar—hand-tossed, thin crust, wings, and cheesy bread—so it’s easy to please a crowd. Order ahead online, and your pies usually show up right about the time everyone’s settled in.
04
Family chain comfort
Pizza Hut
Dover Shopping Corridor • Classic Dine-In And Carryout Chain • Best For Families
Pan pizzas, stuffed crust, and big booths make this a comfortable, predictable option for family pizza night.
If you grew up on pan pizza and red-checkered vibes, the Dover Pizza Hut scratches that nostalgic itch. The menu is built for sharing—big pies, breadsticks, and pitchers of soda—so it’s an easy place to wrangle kids or meet up with relatives. It’s also a handy stop when you’re already running errands up in Dover and want to head back to Mineral City with dinner sorted.
05
Fast and frugal
Little Caesars Pizza
Uhrichsville Main Drag • Carryout-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Best On A Budget
Hot-and-ready pizzas and crazy bread make this a quick, low-cost option when you’re passing through Uhrichsville.
Little Caesars in Uhrichsville is all about speed and value, which is ideal when you’re shuttling between towns and don’t have time to wait. The classic hot-and-ready cheese and pepperoni pies are the move if you just want to grab a box and go. It’s not fancy, but it’s hard to beat for feeding a carload of people without spending much.