01
Best overall pick
Cocca's Pizza – Mineral Ridge
Mineral Ridge Main Street • Takeout-Focused Hometown Pizzeria • Go-To Local Favorite
A Mineral Ridge standby turning out generously topped pies with that classic Mahoning Valley cheese pull.
Cocca’s keeps things straightforward: dough made right, plenty of cheese, and toppings that go edge to edge on the pan. It’s the place locals call first for Friday-night pizza, sheet pizzas for a crowd, or a quick carryout on the way home through town. Expect friendly counter service, fast turnaround, and reliably satisfying comfort pizza.
02
Best for quick weeknight dinners
Pizza Joes – Mineral Ridge
South Mineral Ridge • Neighborhood Delivery Shop • Best For Quick Weeknight Dinners
A convenient spot when you want hot, cheesy pizza and sides delivered without overthinking the order.
Pizza Joes serves the kind of familiar, crowd-pleasing pies that work for just about everyone at the table. The menu leans into classics—pepperoni, sausage, and white pizza—along with wings, subs, and a few kid-approved sides. It’s a reliable call for busy nights when you want something satisfying on the table fast.
03
Best for big orders
Wedgewood Pizza – Austintown
Austintown Raccoon Road Corridor • Classic Mahoning Valley Shop • Best For Party Trays And Big Orders
Beloved in the Valley for hefty, square-cut pizzas that feed a crowd without skimping on toppings.
The Austintown Wedgewood location is a pilgrimage spot for many local pizza fans, especially when there’s a party or game to feed. Signature square pies come with a crisp bottom, airy crumb, and a liberal layer of cheese that hits all four corners. Call ahead for sheet pizzas and specialty combinations if you’re planning to bring pizza for the whole crew.
04
Best sit-down Italian option
Belleria Pizza & Italian Restaurant – Austintown
Austintown Mahoning Avenue Strip • Red-Sauce Italian Restaurant & Bar • Best For Lingering Over A Meal
A full-service spot where you can pair a loaded pie with pasta, salads, and a relaxed dining-room vibe.
Belleria in Austintown offers more than just pizza, but the pies are still the main draw for many regulars. You can build your own or opt for house specialties, then round things out with appetizers, baked pasta, or a carafe of pop for the table. It’s a comfortable choice when you want to sit down, catch up with family, and let the kitchen keep the food coming.
05
Best game-day hangout
Inner Circle Pizza – Niles
Near Eastwood Mall In Niles • Sports Bar-Style Pizza Pub • Best For Game-Day Gatherings
A lively spot for crispy-edged pizza, cold drinks, and watching the game with a group.
Inner Circle in Niles combines a sports-bar atmosphere with a pizza menu that leans into shareable, crunchy-edged pies. The layout and TV setup make it easy to settle in for a full afternoon of football or a midweek Cavs game. It’s a natural choice when you want pizza plus wings, a round of drinks, and a social setting that still feels local.