01
Best old-school classic
The Pizza House
Northland Near Cleveland Avenue • Old-School Columbus-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A North Side institution turning out crackery-thin, square-cut pies that feel tailor-made for a casual night close to Minerva Park.
The Pizza House has been serving the north side for decades, and it shows in the confident simplicity of its crispy, edge-to-edge pizzas. Toppings lean classic, but the balance of cheese, sauce, and crunch is what keeps regulars coming back. It is an easy go-to for carryout when you want something reliable and distinctly Columbus-style.
02
Best sit-down option
Borgata Pizza Cafe
Westerville - Schrock Road • Casual Italian Cafe And Pizzeria • Best For Lingering Dinners
A relaxed Westerville spot combining well-crafted pies, pastas, and a solid wine and beer list just a short hop north of Minerva Park.
Borgata Pizza Cafe is a good choice when you want more than just a quick box of slices, with a full menu and a dining room that suits both families and small groups. The pizzas skew generous, with chewy, foldable crusts and toppings like spicy Italian sausage or fresh basil that feel a notch above standard carryout. Pair a pie with a salad and a drink and you have an easy weeknight dinner without heading downtown.
03
Best for watching the game
JT's Pizza & Pub
Worthington / Linworth • Lively Sports Bar And Pizzeria • Game-Day Pick
A noisy, friendly pub where big screens, craft beers, and over-the-top specialty pizzas make it worth the short drive west.
JT's Pizza & Pub leans into the sports-bar energy, so expect a full slate of games on TV and a menu that does not shy away from loaded toppings. The crust is substantial enough to handle combos piled with meats, veggies, or creative sauces, and there are plenty of wings and appetizers if you are settling in for a full game. It is especially popular for Buckeye football Saturdays and casual nights out with friends.
04
Best for big groups
Massey's Pizza
East Dublin-Granville Corridor • Carryout-Focused Columbus-Style Chain • Group-Friendly Favorite
A long-running local chain known for party-cut thin crusts and easy online ordering, ideal when you're feeding a crowd near Minerva Park.
Massey's keeps things streamlined with familiar flavors, quick service, and sizes that scale up easily for gatherings. The signature thin crust holds up well for delivery and reheating, and the menu covers everything from classic pepperoni to loaded deluxe combinations. It is the kind of place locals bookmark for birthday parties, team celebrations, or any night when multiple boxes on the table are non-negotiable.
05
Best late-night carryout
Terita's Pizza
North Columbus / Cleveland Avenue • No-Frills Takeout Pizza Joint • Late-Night Pick
A beloved north-side standby turning out saucy, cheesy pies that hit the spot when you want something straightforward and satisfying.
Terita's has built its reputation on consistency rather than flash, with a slightly thicker, doughy crust and plenty of cheese and sauce on every order. It is an easy, no-fuss choice for late evenings when cooking is off the table and you just want hot pizza in a box. Expect efficient service, familiar flavors, and that classic corner-shop feel many north-end residents grew up with.