01
Closest to home
Hillsboro Grill & Tavern
Mingo Junction Hilltop • Neighborhood Tavern With Hearty Bar-Style Pizza • Best Bar-Style Pizza Close To Mingo
A laid-back Mingo Junction tavern where locals grab a crisp, cheesy pie with a cold drink after work.
If you want to stay in the village and still get a solid pizza, Hillsboro Grill & Tavern is the obvious move. The pies lean classic bar style: sturdy crust, plenty of cheese, and generous toppings meant to stand up to wings and draft beer. It’s an easy, no-frills choice when you want to watch the game and not worry about driving into town.
02
Local classic
DiCarlo's Pizza
Downtown Steubenville • Ohio Valley Square-Cut Pizzeria • Classic Local Staple
The area’s signature stop for Ohio Valley–style squares topped with cheese after they come out of the oven.
DiCarlo's is the name most people around Mingo mention first when you ask about pizza. Expect that distinct Ohio Valley style: airy, crunchy-edged squares with sauce and crust baked hot, then finished with a blanket of cool shredded cheese and pepperoni. It’s an old-school counter operation, so grab a box of squares and eat them in the car while they’re still at peak crunch.
03
Independent favorite
Pilot Pizza
Steubenville Riverfront • Casual Mom-And-Pop Pizza Shop • Best Small-Shop Pie
A compact riverfront shop turning out well-topped pies that feel more homemade than chain-style.
Pilot Pizza is the kind of place people keep in their phone under “pizza” and call without thinking twice. The crust sits in that sweet spot between soft and crisp, with toppings that run generous rather than fussy. It’s a good bet when you want a straightforward, filling pizza from a local shop instead of another national name.
04
Delivery workhorse
Domino's Pizza
Sunset Boulevard Corridor, Steubenville • Busy National Delivery Chain • Best For Fast, Customizable Delivery
A reliable option for late-night or last-minute orders, with lots of crust styles and topping combos.
When the priority is speed and predictability, the Domino’s on Sunset tends to be the go-to for people in and around Mingo Junction. The menu covers everything from thin-crust pepperoni to heavier specialty pies, plus sides that make it easy to feed a mixed group. Online ordering and tracking are straightforward, which helps when you’re coordinating food for a game night or kids’ sleepover.
05
Budget pick
Little Caesars Pizza
Freedom Way Commercial Strip • Take-And-Go Value Pizza Chain • Best On A Budget
A quick-stop spot for hot-and-ready pies when you need to feed a crowd without overthinking it.
Little Caesars on Freedom Way is all about convenience and price, which makes it popular for team dinners, kids’ parties, and busy weeknights. The hot-and-ready format means you can usually walk in, grab a pepperoni or cheese pizza, and be back in the car in minutes. It’s not trying to be gourmet; it’s there to get plenty of slices on the table fast and cheaply.