01
Best overall pick
The Hangry Hornet
American Way Retail Strip • Creative Local Pizzeria • Neighborhood Favorite
Family-run shop turning out chewy-crisp crusts, creative topping combos, and hearty portions at fair prices.
Tucked just off American Way, The Hangry Hornet feels like the kind of place regulars put on speed dial. Pizzas come loaded, with well-seasoned sauce, a sturdy crust that holds up under toppings, and fun rotating specials. It is an easy choice when you want something more personal than a big national chain without driving far.
02
Best for families
LaRosa's Pizzeria Monroe
Heritage Green Shopping Area • Family-Friendly Regional Chain • Best For Families
Lively LaRosa's outpost with a big menu, roomy dining room, and reliably kid-pleasing pies.
This Monroe location of Cincinnati’s beloved LaRosa’s brand is a go-to for teams, birthday dinners, and multi-generation family outings. The crust leans soft and bready, with classic toppings, specialty pies, hoagys, and pastas to keep everyone happy. Service is used to handling large groups, making it a low-stress option on busy evenings.
03
Old-school favorite
Richard's Pizza
Heritage Green Corridor • Classic Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Best For Thin, Square-Cut Pies
Local chain known for thin, square-cut pies topped edge-to-edge with cheese and pepperoni.
Richard’s has been an Ohio staple for decades, and the Monroe shop keeps that tradition alive. Expect a nostalgic, slightly sweet sauce, a thin crust cut into squares, and generous toppings that go right to the edge. It is a smart pick when you are craving classic Midwest pizza and want leftovers for the fridge.
04
Carryout classic
Cassano's Pizza King
North Main Street • No-Frills Carryout Joint • Quick Takeout Option
Old-school regional chain serving cracker-thin, party-cut pies ideal for fast pickup.
Cassano’s Monroe spot leans hard into its carryout roots: order ahead, swing by North Main, and head home with hot pizza in minutes. The crust is notably thin and crisp, with a salty, nostalgic flavor that pairs well with classic toppings like pepperoni and sausage. It is especially handy on weeknights when you want something quick without resorting to generic delivery.
05
Worth the drive
Two Cities Pizza Co.
Mason, Off I-75 • Chicago-And-New York–Style Pizzeria • Destination Pick Near Monroe
Playful Mason pizzeria riffing on both Chicago deep dish and New York foldable slices in one spot.
If you are up for a short drive south, Two Cities is the place locals recommend when they want a pizza night to feel like an outing. The menu lets you choose between buttery, cornmeal-crusted Chicago-style pies and wide, foldable New York slices, all with thoughtful toppings and craft-beer pairings. Its brick-laden, city-themed dining room gives it a fun, special-occasion feel without being stuffy.