01
Best overall pick
Pean's Pizza, Subs & Sudz
Downtown Monroeville • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria And Pub • Local Favorite
The go-to spot in Monroeville for loaded pies, subs, and a low-key beer-friendly atmosphere.
Right on South Main Street, Pean's is the kind of place where staff know regulars by name and the pizza feels made for the town. Crusts are sturdy enough to handle plenty of toppings, and the menu leans hearty with subs, wings, and bar-style appetizers. It’s an easy first choice for game nights, casual dinners, or a laid-back bite with friends after work.
02
Best for big groups
East of Chicago Pizza
Norwalk Commercial Strip • Buffet-Friendly, Pan-Pizza Chain • Best For Families
A short drive from Monroeville, this spot is known for thick pan and specialty pizzas that feed a crowd without fuss.
East of Chicago in Norwalk is popular with families who want plenty of food for not a lot of planning. The crust runs thicker and softer, with options ranging from classic pepperoni to loaded taco and chicken-bacon-ranch styles. It’s a reliable choice when you’re organizing a team outing, birthday party, or need a stack of pizzas that will keep everyone happy.
03
Best for classic Ohio-style pizza
Cameo Pizza
Norwalk Downtown Area • Long-Running Regional Pizzeria • Old-School Favorite
A regional name with roots on Lake Erie, Cameo serves thin, edge-to-edge pizzas that many locals grew up on.
Cameo Pizza brings that familiar Northern Ohio style: crisp crust, sauce with a bit of zip, and toppings spread right out to the edge. It strikes a nice balance between dine-in and takeout, working just as well for a casual night out as it does for grabbing a couple boxes to go. If you like your pizza straightforward, nostalgic, and not overly fussy, this is the Norwalk stop to put on your list.
04
Best for customizable carryout
Marco's Pizza
Norwalk East Side • Carryout And Delivery-Focused Chain • Weeknight Standby
A dependable option for build-your-own pies, cheesy bread, and salads when you want quick carryout from Norwalk.
Marco's in Norwalk is ideal for those nights when cooking is off the table and you want something familiar. The menu leans heavily into customization, with different crusts, sauces, and topping combinations that make it easy to please picky eaters. It’s close enough to Monroeville for a practical pickup run, especially if you’re grabbing pizza on the way home from errands in town.
05
Best for dine-in nostalgia
Pizza Hut
Bellevue Highway Corridor • Casual Sit-Down Chain Pizzeria • Comfort Pick
The Bellevue Pizza Hut delivers that familiar pan-pizza comfort with a sit-down option a short drive from Monroeville.
For many locals, Pizza Hut is synonymous with childhood pizza nights, and the Bellevue location keeps that feel intact. The pan pizzas come out with that signature buttery crust, and there’s usually enough space for families or small groups to spread out in a booth. It’s a solid option when you’re already out along the highway and want a no-surprises stop for pizza, breadsticks, and a relaxed sit-down meal.