01
Best overall pick
Celina Wine Store
Downtown Celina • Wine Bar With Artisan Pizzas • Local Favorite
A downtown Celina staple where well-crafted pizzas share the spotlight with a smart wine and beer lineup.
Despite the name, Celina Wine Store feels more like a laid-back bistro than a shop, with a menu of crisp, generously topped pizzas that pair well with anything on their drink list. The crust is thin but sturdy, with toppings that lean a bit more gourmet than your average pie. It’s an easy go-to when you want something nicer than takeout but still relaxed and unpretentious.
02
Best lakeside stop
Bayview Pub
Lakeside In Celina • Lakeside Pub With Crispy Pies • Best For Lake Views
Casual lakeside pub fare with pizzas that taste especially good after a day on Grand Lake.
Bayview Pub leans into its waterfront setting, serving pizzas that go hand in hand with a cold drink and a view of the marina. The pies skew classic—lots of pepperoni, sausage, and veggie combos—on a crust that lands between thin and hand-tossed. It’s the spot you pick when you want a laid-back, post-boat bite without leaving the lake scene behind.
03
Best sit-down Italian
Bella's Italian Grille
Grand Lake Shoreline In Celina • Italian Grill With Stone-Baked Pizza • Best Date-Night Pick
Lakeside Italian dining where the pizzas hold their own alongside pastas and steaks.
Bella’s Italian Grille is known first for its full Italian menu, but the pizzas are a quiet standout, with nicely blistered crusts and thoughtful topping combinations. The dining room and patio overlook Grand Lake, making it an easy choice when you want pizza without sacrificing atmosphere. It works just as well for a relaxed date night as it does for a family celebration.
04
Most familiar choice
Pizza Hut
East Celina Shopping Strip • Classic Chain Pizzeria • Best For Families
A reliable option for pan pizzas, breadsticks, and big-group orders a short drive from Montezuma.
The Celina Pizza Hut is exactly what many families around Montezuma count on for an easy pizza night: familiar pies, quick service, and plenty of options to keep kids happy. Pan and stuffed-crust pizzas are the main draw, backed up by wings and the usual sides. It’s especially convenient when you need to feed a crowd without overthinking where to go.
05
Best small-town classic
Guarnieri Pizzeria
Village Center In St. Henry • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Worth-The-Drive Classic
A cozy, no-frills pizzeria known for hearty, square-cut pies that travel well back to Montezuma.
Guarnieri Pizzeria in nearby St. Henry feels like the kind of place locals have relied on for decades, with straightforward, generously cheesed pizzas cut into party squares. The menu sticks to the hits—pepperoni, deluxe, and meat-heavy combos—but does them with care and consistency. Call ahead, grab your boxes, and you’ll be back in Montezuma with hot pizza before it even has time to cool.