01
Best overall pick
Taglio Montgomery
Montgomery Road Corridor • Detroit- And New York-Style Pizzeria And Bar • Craft Pizza With A Lively Bar Vibe
A polished spot for crispy-edged Detroit-style and classic round pies with a strong drink lineup.
Taglio’s Montgomery location is the place locals recommend when you want pizza to feel like a night out, not just takeout. The thick, caramelized‑crust Detroit squares are the headliners, but the New York-style rounds and creative toppings keep the menu interesting. TVs at the bar, a solid beer list, and reliable service make it easy to linger with friends or catch a game.
02
Classic neighborhood slice
Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta
Old Montgomery • Classic New York-Style Slice Shop • Neighborhood Staple
Casual counter-service pies that feel like a New York slice shop dropped into Montgomery.
Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta is the spot for foldable, thin slices and no-nonsense red‑sauce comfort. Families gravitate here for big shared pies, garlic knots, and familiar pasta dishes that please a crowd. The straightforward setup makes it an easy weeknight option when you want good pizza without any fuss.
03
Fast and filling carryout
Jet's Pizza Montgomery
Montgomery Road Strip • Carryout Detroit-Style Chain Pizzeria • Best For Quick Takeout
Dependable, cheesy Detroit-style pans and boneless wings ready for fast pickup or delivery.
Jet’s is a go‑to when you need hearty, square‑cut pan pizza on the table in a hurry. The crust is thick, airy, and edged with that signature crisp cheese, and the menu covers everything from customizable toppings to subs and salads. It is especially handy for busy nights, kids’ sleepovers, or those times when you want maximum pizza with minimal effort.
04
Game-night standby
Donatos Pizza – Kenwood Road
Kenwood And Blue Ash Line • Thin-Crust Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Best For Sharing With A Crowd
Ultra-thin, edge-to-edge toppings make these pizzas ideal for feeding a group without feeling too heavy.
Just down the road toward Kenwood, this Donatos is a reliable choice when you are ordering for a bigger group. The signature thin crust and generous toppings make it easy to sample a few different combinations without overdoing it. Add in salads and wings and you have an uncomplicated spread for movie night, watch parties, or casual get‑togethers.
05
Worth-the-drive destination
Two Cities Pizza Co.
Mason, A Short Drive North • New York And Chicago-Style Destination Pizzeria • Best For A Planned Pizza Outing
A popular suburban spot where you can compare classic New York slices and hearty Chicago deep dish under one roof.
Two Cities in Mason is a favorite weekend drive for Montgomery residents who take their pizza seriously. The menu lets you pick sides in the New York versus Chicago debate or mix it up with both styles at the table. Expect a busy, upbeat dining room, shareable appetizers, and pies substantial enough to turn dinner into an event.