01
Best overall pick
Tano's Pizza Montpelier
Downtown Montpelier • Classic Small-Town Pizza Shop • Local Go-To For Carryout
A long-running local favorite known for hearty, square-cut pies and wallet-friendly specials.
Tano's in downtown Montpelier is the kind of place locals grow up on, with pizzas that lean generous on toppings and cheese. The menu covers all the classics plus a few loaded specialty combinations that feed a crowd without much fuss. Call ahead for carryout on busy weekend nights, when family game nights and team parties tend to fill the ticket queue.
02
Most reliable chain option
Marco's Pizza Montpelier
Whitaker Way Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Best For Game-Night Delivery
A familiar national name turning out consistently good pizzas, subs, and wings just off Whitaker Way.
Marco's is the dependable choice when you want a hot pizza delivered without overthinking the order. You can build your own pie or stick with their well-tested specialty lineup, and the crust options let you tweak it to your style. It is especially handy for larger orders on busy weeknights or when you are hosting a last-minute get-together.
03
Best grab-and-go stop
Nettie's Stop & Shop
East Side Of Montpelier • Convenience Stop With Hot Pizza • Quick Bite On The Way Through Town
A low-key convenience-style stop where you can fuel up and grab a hot, satisfying slice or whole pie.
Nettie's pairs small-town convenience with made-to-order pizza, making it an easy choice when you are already out running errands or passing through. The pies are straightforward and filling, ideal if you want something hot without a long wait or complicated menu. It is a practical option for road-trippers and locals alike who value speed and simplicity.
04
Best nearby branch outside town
Tano's Pizza Bryan
Bryan, South Of Montpelier • Regional Chain Storefront • Best For Families And Big Orders
A larger Tano's outpost in Bryan that keeps the familiar pies coming for family dinners and team parties.
If you find yourself in Bryan, the Tano's there offers the same crowd-pleasing pizzas Montpelier regulars know, with plenty of room for big family orders. It is a convenient option when you are combining a grocery run or errands in the county seat with dinner plans. Call ahead for multiple pies or party trays, especially on weekends when it gets busy with local events.
05
Best farther-afield option
Tano's Pizza Wauseon
Wauseon, East Of Montpelier • Highway-Adjacent Regional Pizzeria • Good Stop On Longer Drives
East of Montpelier, this Tano's makes familiar Northwest Ohio pies an easy stop on the way toward Fulton County and beyond.
For Montpelier folks heading east or travelers coming off the highway, Tano's in Wauseon is a reliable place to break up the drive with a hot pizza. The menu mirrors the other locations, so you can stick with a favorite combination or try something new without any surprises. It is a smart pick if you want a sit-down breather instead of another fast-food stop on the road.