01
Old-school local classic
Jac & Do's Pizza
Downtown Findlay • Retro Hometown Pizzeria • Best For Classic Pies
A long-running local favorite turning out generously topped, no-nonsense pizzas at fair prices.
Jac & Do's is the kind of place locals grew up with, and it still feels like a small-town pizza parlor in the best way. The crust is sturdy but not too thick, with plenty of cheese and toppings that lean toward the traditional. It is an easy pick when you want a straightforward pepperoni or deluxe without overthinking it.
02
Big-group crowd-pleaser
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
Tiffin Avenue Corridor • Lively Sports-Bar Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Game Nights
Hearty, shareable pizzas served alongside wings, sandwiches, and plenty of TVs for the game.
Beer Barrel works well when you have a mixed crew and not everyone is laser-focused on pizza. The menu runs from loaded specialty pies to baked pasta and big salads, so everyone can find something. With a full bar and lots of seating, it is a natural choice for weeknight teams, family birthdays, or catching a game after a short drive from Mount Blanchard.
03
Neighborhood carryout favorite
Heavenly Pizza
North Main Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Takeout Night
A local shop known for friendly service, soft‑chewy crusts, and reliable delivery.
Heavenly Pizza leans into comfort food, with crust that is a bit thicker and softer than most and toppings piled generously. It hits the spot when you want a box of pizza, some cheesy bread, and maybe wings to take home. Order ahead on busy nights, as many locals treat it as their go-to for Friday or game-day carryout.
04
Reliable chain go-to
Marco's Pizza
West Findlay • Familiar National Chain • Best For Quick, Customizable Orders
A convenient option with consistent pizzas, lots of topping choices, and easy online ordering.
Marco's is a solid choice when you want something predictable and fast after a drive back from town. The menu leans on build-your-own pies, plus specialty options and oven-baked subs. It is especially handy for families who want to split a couple of large pizzas and add a pan of cheesy bread or a salad without spending much.
05
Late-night standby
Domino's Pizza
East Findlay • Fast-Delivery Chain Shop • Best For Late-Night Cravings
Fast, predictable pizza and sides that stay open later than many local spots.
When other kitchens have closed and you still want a hot pizza, Domino's usually has you covered. The menu is familiar—hand-tossed, thin, or pan crust, plus wings, pasta, and desserts—and the online tracker makes it simple to time your pickup or delivery. It is not the most romantic pick, but it is hard to beat for sheer convenience from the Mount Blanchard area.