01
Best overall pick
Padrone's Pizza - Bluffton
Downtown Bluffton • Family-Friendly Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A go-to Bluffton staple with hearty pies, friendly service, and a small-town crowd that keeps coming back.
Just a quick drive northwest of Mount Cory, Padrone's in Bluffton feels like the kind of place where everyone knows your order. The crust hits that sweet spot between soft and crisp, with toppings piled on generously and plenty of classic combos. It’s a reliable choice for everything from post-game team meals to low-key Friday night carryout.
02
Best for variety
East of Chicago Pizza - Bluffton
Bluffton Main Corridor • Classic Midwest Pizza Buffet And Carryout • Best For Big Groups
Buffet-style comfort pizza with lots of topping choices, plus wings and subs that make feeding a crowd simple.
East of Chicago in Bluffton is the spot when you need to keep a whole crew happy without overthinking it. The buffet lineup and thick, cheesy pan pizzas are tailor-made for families, teams, and youth groups. It’s casual, affordable, and close enough to Mount Cory for an easy weeknight outing.
03
Old-school favorite
Jac & Do's Pizza - Findlay
West Findlay • Old-School Local Pizza Joint • Best Nostalgic Vibe
Thin, crispy-edged pies and a laid-back, slightly retro feel that many Findlay-area locals grew up with.
Jac & Do's is one of those names that pops up whenever longtime locals talk about pizza in the Findlay area. The crust runs on the thinner side with crisp edges, perfect for those who like to polish off a few extra slices. From Mount Cory, it’s an easy hop east for carryout or a relaxed dine-in that feels pleasantly old-school.
04
Best for game day
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill - Findlay
Eastside Findlay Retail Strip • Lively Sports Bar And Pizza Grill • Best For Sports Fans
Big, shareable pizzas served alongside wings, burgers, and plenty of TVs tuned to the game.
If you’re planning a night out with friends instead of a quick grab-and-go, Beer Barrel in Findlay is worth the drive from Mount Cory. The pizzas come out large and loaded, designed to sit in the middle of the table while everyone picks at wings and appetizers. The energetic, TV-filled atmosphere makes it the natural choice for watching Buckeyes, Browns, or high school playoff games.
05
Best for delivery from Findlay
Heavenly Pizza - Findlay
Central Findlay • Faith-Based Community Pizza Shop • Best For Delivery And Takeout
A community-minded shop turning out sturdy, cheese-heavy pies that travel well for takeout or delivery.
Heavenly Pizza has built a loyal following around Findlay with straightforward, satisfying pizzas and a service-first attitude. The crust is sturdy enough to hold generous cheese and toppings, which makes their pies ideal for the drive back toward Mount Cory. It’s a smart pick when you want dependable delivery or carryout from town without fuss or frills.