01
Best neighborhood classic
Angilo's Pizza & Hoagies
Mount Healthy Business District • Classic Cincinnati-Style Pizzeria • Old-School Local Favorite
Cracker-thin, topping-heavy pies and hefty hoagies anchor this no-frills Mount Healthy staple.
Angilo's feels like the kind of place people grow up with and never stop ordering from. The pizza leans thin and crisp with a generous layer of cheese and toppings, plus a sauce that runs more savory than sweet. Add in their hoagies and spaghetti dinners and it’s an easy go-to when you want a low-key, reliably local meal.
02
Best for big family orders
LaRosa's Pizzeria – Mount Healthy
Hamilton Avenue Strip • Family-Friendly Cincinnati Chain • Best For Families And Groups
A Mount Healthy outpost of the hometown chain known for sweet sauce, big menus, and crowd-pleasing pizzas.
If you’re feeding a mixed crew, LaRosa’s is the safest bet in the area. Their trademark sweet-leaning sauce, customizable crusts, and long list of toppings make it easy to keep everyone happy, from kids to picky adults. Round it out with wings, salads, and pastas and you’re set for game night or a casual family gathering.
03
Best sauce-heavy slices
Italianette Pizza
North College Hill On West Galbraith • Hearty Neighborhood Pizza Joint • Carryout Standout
Robust, saucy pies and old-school charm make Italianette worth the quick hop from Mount Healthy.
Italianette has the kind of slightly cramped, always-busy feel that signals a serious carryout following. The pizzas skew on the heavier side, with plenty of cheese and a bold, tomato-forward sauce that stands up to thick-cut toppings. It’s the spot you call when you want a classic Cincinnati-area pie that can hold its own on the drive home.
04
Best crispy-edge pies
Chester's Pizza
White Oak, Short Drive South • Old-School West Side Pizza Parlor • West Side Favorite
A beloved West Side mainstay turning out crisp-edged, cheese-laden pizzas just minutes from Mount Healthy.
Chester’s draws loyalists from across the West Side for its well-done, edge-to-edge cheese pizzas with a satisfying crunch. The recipes lean nostalgic, and you’ll see plenty of multi-generational families picking up the same orders they’ve had for years. It’s a quick drive from Mount Healthy and a solid choice when you’re craving a classic Cincinnati neighborhood pie with personality.
05
Best fast, familiar option
Pizza Hut – Mount Healthy
West Galbraith Road Corridor • National Delivery And Carryout Chain • Reliable Delivery Choice
A convenient Mount Healthy hub for stuffed crust, pan pizzas, and quick delivery when convenience matters most.
For nights when speed and predictability beat exploration, the local Pizza Hut gets the job done. You’ll find the full lineup of familiar options, from pan and thin crust to stuffed crust, plus wings and sides to round out the order. It’s especially handy for late-week dinners or last-minute game-day deliveries when you don’t want to overthink it.